HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >


Trying to make a lower fat slaw

This is a multi part question.
I'm trying to mimic what is called "crunchy vegetable slaw" in my supermarket. It's ingredients are:
broccoli slaw
borccolit florets
dried cranberries
sunflower seeds
and of course a mayo based slaw dressing.

If they weren't charging $5.99/lb I would probably not be asking this question but since I want to make it myself, I'm trying to figure out how to make a good/lower fat slaw dressing. I've tried mixing reduced fat mayo with champagne vinegar but that didn't do it. Does anyone here have a recipe that will solve my problem?. Thanks in advance for your help.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. what about using a mixture of regular mayo and greek yogurt? or regular yogurt if the greek is too thick?

    1. mix a low fat sour cream or yogurt with your low fat mayo and rice vinegar

      1. You really don't have to use mayo, use more vinegar (I've tried others but always go back to Heinz white) and lemon juice with a bit of yougurt instead. It's a refreshing change from all mayo. Make a vinegrette kind of dressing and add just a spoonful or two of yougurt or even mayo if that's what you like.

        1. Perhaps the champagne vinegar was too mild to have any pronounced effect on the broccoli and dressing. I suggest using apple cider vinegar, or any other assertive vinegar, along with the mayo but cut the mayo with drained non-fat yogurt. Season with course sea salt and freshly grated black pepper.

          1. I agree with the yogurt suggestions, but I also love buttermilk-based slaw dressing. With all these subs I find the key is to use *some* fat. My choice would be full-fat mayo. Low-fat mayo is basically watered down mayo to me and you're going to be watering it down with the yogurt/buttermilk anyway. Anyway, I find most mayo-rich recipes you can sub sour cream, greek yogurt or buttermilk (for a dressing, not a dip obviously) but you need *some* mayo in there. Start with a heaping tablespoon and taste until it hits the spot. It won't be low-fat strictly speaking but it will be LOWER fat and still very tasty. If you are used to a lower-fat diet you will probably need less mayo than someone who is just starting to cut back. I find this yields much more satisfying results than just subbing in 100% low fat yogurt, and you might even make the healthier recipe again :)

            2 Replies
              1. re: katecm

                Thanks Katecm, I went to the website and made the dressing. Outrageous! I will be keeping a jar of it in the fridge to put on salads or as a dip. Just have to make it a little thicker. Left it in the fridge on the broc. slaw and it got somewhat watery overnight. Thanks for your advice.

            1. I've been using Bittman's "no mayo" slaw dressing every once in a while...nice change from the usual

              1. If you like the creaminess of mayo, try subing a low-fat buttermilk with a sharp hit of cider vinegar in your dressing. The tartness from both provides a nice tang to slaw.

                1. I've never had your slaw, but I'd recommend pickle juice to cut the mayonnaise. I find the juice from Sechler's candied dill pickles quite useful.

                  1. There are all sorts of possibilities, beginning with how you define "low fat." That can range all the way from literally NO fat, to almost-high fat. Markets are full of possibilities. Fat free sour cream, and some brands are better than others. The best are hardly distinguishable from full fat sour cream. What to mix with it? There are several brands of mayonnaise that run the gamut from no to low to high fat. My personal preference is Hellmann's low fat (1 gram of fat per tablespoon), which is lower in fat than their "reduced fat" mayonnaise (which comes in at 2g of fat per Tbsp, so why do they bother???). You'v e GOT to read labels! Kraft makes a fat free mayonnaise, but it is less "mayonnaisy" than Hellmann's. A blender takes options even farther afield. Low fat and no fat cottage cheese, buttermilk, ricotta, and cream cheese. All sorts of vinegars, and sweeteners that range from sugar or honey to fresh fruits or preserves. Poppy seeds are a popular addition to cole slaw. Sunflower seeds, pine nuts, almonds, walnuts, hazelnuts. The bottom line is that you are the only one with the mental profile of the flavor you're looking for, so it sounds like time to play! And keep in mind that no mistake is really a mistake (loss) if you learn something from it. Happy creating and have fun with it!

                    2 Replies
                    1. re: Caroline1

                      Love Duke's Light. The difference between it and regular Dukes (the king of mayo) is not a deal breaker for me. 5 grams/Tbl , so you can't just go nuts with it, but it's better than 12 per.

                      For slaws and salads like Waldorf, I use abotu 75% low fat greek yogurt nad 25% Dukes light. I would add vinegar and SUGAR to the broccoli salad if I were the OP.

                      1. re: danna

                        In fact I did add cider vinegar and a little sugar to the recipe and it turned out great. Thanks for the Info.

                    2. Thank you all for your advice.

                      1. One thing about slaw is that you can drain it or even squeeze it and it still retains taste.

                        2 Replies
                        1. re: wekick

                          I'll try that tonight. Thanks

                          1. re: jnk

                            It has to be mixed long enough to absorb the dressing and "pickle" a little--maybe 12 hours or so.

                        2. Use seasoned rice vinegar on plain shredded cabbage and you've got something very like what they serve at Japanese restaurants.

                          1. What did you end up going with? I have found a similar recipe that I love at my supermarket, but it also has cauliflower and carrots in it. I really would love to be able to make it! I want to make it healthier and of course less than $5.99 per lb.