HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What have you made lately?
TELL US

Canoodling at Balthazar: Still crazy good after all these years

TrishUntrapped Oct 7, 2012 04:20 PM

There's just something about Balthazar - good food, drinks, fun atmosphere, that keeps me coming back year after year to celebrate a birthday or anniversary, or to bring first time visitors to NYC.

My husband and I recently enjoyed our 30th anniversary dinner there. We were early and started with cocktails at the bar. I walked by a guy sipping a three-toned drink and asked him what it was. He said it was the best Mojito he'd ever had. That being one of my favorites, I ordered it too, and concur. As Mary Poppins might say, it was practically perfect in every way.

Our extremely cordial and welcoming server brought us to what I call a "canoodling" table. A round table where we could sit next to each other and canoodle. Which in our case meant eat, drink and laugh. She also brought us a couple flutes of champagne on the house for our anniversary. ;-) Excellent service.

For dinner we enjoyed the Balthazar Salad, French Onion Soup, Grilled Lamb T Bones, and the Saturday special - Short Ribs. We had been toying with ordering the Cote du Boeuf for two which is my very favorite steak in the city, but hubby had eaten steak the night before and wanted lamb. No problemo. All the food was excellent. Well prepared. There was a little too much bread in the onion soup for me, but the favor was great. Right now, Artisanal makes my favorite one. Whatever you order at Balthazar, get the frites!

Even though dinner was more than enough, and we were taking home leftovers, it was our special day so we got dessert. Profiteroles - three ice cream filled cream puffs covered with rich delicious chocolate, and my husband's favorite - Lemon Mille Feuille - a hand-formed lemon Napoleon, lemon granite and what they call lemon parfait. If you like lemon, get this one.

See you next year, Balthazar.

Photos:

1. Free bar snacks include hard-boiled eggs and olives.
2. Outstanding Mojito,left, and a Margarita.
3. The seafood case en route to our table.
4. Complimentary champagne.
5. Our happy server.
6. Balthazar bread - densely good.
7. French Onion Soup.
8. Frites.
9. Lamb T Bones.
10. Short Ribs.
11. Profiteroles
12. Lemon Mille-Feuille

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  1. iluvcookies Oct 7, 2012 06:16 PM

    What a lovely review! Happy Anniversary to you both.

    I'll admit, I've gotten coffee and croissaints there many times, but have never eaten in the restaurant. Looks like I've been missing out.

    1. l
      lalabama Oct 7, 2012 06:52 PM

      I have been coming to NYC every year for 24 years with a group of friends and Balthazar is the one place we want to go back to every year.

      1. michele cindy Oct 9, 2012 11:45 AM

        Great photos! I usually go at lunch. Hoping they have the lamb steak one day. Happy anniversary!

        1. TrishUntrapped Oct 9, 2012 12:28 PM

          Thanks everyone, we had a blast!

          Show Hidden Posts