HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >
What have you made lately?
TELL US

lets talk about Roasting Pans . . . again

blackbookali Sep 26, 2012 11:17 AM

Hey everyone,

I have looked at some old threads and since this is America and something new and shiny comes out every 5 minutes I wanted to raise up a discussion about Roasting Pans. I have a beat up one from Surfas(LA restaurant supply store) that does the job though I find it burns my aromatics(mire poixe) more than I like, even though I add stock like a good cook should.

I ponder replacing this and yet I hesitate on dropping $200 for an All Clad(even though I love All Clad). Also, for everyday roasting, not that I roast everyday, I love love love love using my iron skillet, man it so does the job and make a fine pan sauce. I wonder if some sort of enameled roasting pan would be the "roasting pan of my dreams".

So here is the deal, should and everyone else who can, pull the trigger on the All Clad? Is the Calphalon a better bang for your buck? Any non stick fans out there? Whats the deal with tri ply? Here is hoping this will become a definitive thread on this subject.

Thanks,

BBA

  1. g
    GH1618 Sep 26, 2012 11:34 AM

    I like my All-Clad pots and pans, but I can't imagine springing for a shiny A-C roasting pan. For that matter, I don't want any stainless steel or multi-ply roasting pan. Nor do I want a nonstick lining. I looked at and rejected all those and bought the de Buyer, which is just plain steel, and quite heavy. It's the best as far as I am concerned, but it may not be available in the US anymore.

    4 Replies
    1. re: GH1618
      g
      GH1618 Sep 26, 2012 11:51 AM

      I just noticed that the A-C roasting pan has been marked down to about the price of the de Buyer. I still don't want it.

      1. re: GH1618
        w
        wattacetti Sep 26, 2012 11:59 AM

        The current deBuyer is a non-stick. I haven't been able to find a listing for the Mineral carbon steel.

        1. re: wattacetti
          g
          GH1618 Sep 26, 2012 01:07 PM

          http://www.jlhufford.com/ProductDetai...

          1. re: GH1618
            b
            blaireso Feb 18, 2013 07:24 PM

            I want it!

    2. w
      wattacetti Sep 26, 2012 11:57 AM

      An enameled roasting pan such as a LeCreuset is going to cost about as much as the All-Clad.

      I have the All-Clad though one of the reasons was that I got it for $120 or so with the insert rack and the turkey lifter forks to boot (one of the few good things about that last trip to Gainesville). It works very well and it doesn't burn things unless you intentionally set it up to burn (or forget to watch over things). The turkey things are handy to have when one makes porchetta.

      I have used a similar Kitchen-Aid and the results are slightly difference because the walls of the pan are slightly taller than the All-Clad. It sells for about $50.

      I know people who like their Calphalon but I have never roasted with one.

      1. m
        MelMM Sep 26, 2012 12:46 PM

        Well, you didn't say what you want to roast in your roasting pan, so it's hard to recommend one. I have an All-Clad roasting pan - a really huge one. It's so big, it is really only good if you are roasting a 20-lb turkey, which I never, ever do. For everyday roasting, I have a Staub enameled cast iron pan, which is great. I also have a slightly smaller La Crueset enameled CI pan that is just a tad smaller and will fit in my Breville countertop convection/toaster oven. That is my preferred pan (and oven) for roasting a chicken, but if I'm going to roast in a normal oven, I prefer the Staub.

        I think the thing is to figure out what you are going to be roasting, and how big a pan you need. Generally, I've found you don't need a really big pan, and in fact, too big a pan just makes the juices evaporate and burn. Heck, as you probably know, you can roast a chicken in a cast iron skillet.

        I would say given your experience with cast iron, you would love a Staub or LC roasting pan. If you need to go for a really big pan, then you can switch to All-Clad or another brand. I don't really think the brand matters that much with a roasting pan, but I would say that non-stick is unnecessary.

        1. j
          janniecooks Sep 26, 2012 01:14 PM

          Sounds to me like your iron skillet IS the roasting pan of your dreams. What's wrong with that?

          I often roast chickens in a stainless tri-ply skillet, or in a ceramic baking pan, or on an aluminum quarter sheet pan. And if I do a beef roast, I'll use a skillet or an appropriately sized Calphalon saute pan. My experience is that a roaster that is too big or has a dark or black surface is what causes the pan juices to scorch, more than the material.

          I see no need to have a dedicated roasting pan, except for the huge Thanksgiving turkey. Since that must be larger and used only once a year, I use an inexpensive roaster bought for that purpose.

          1. kaleokahu Sep 26, 2012 01:19 PM

            Hi, blackbookali:

            I think roasters are sort of counterintuitive. You only really need conductive metal *out* of the oven, but the *surface* makes a difference, and correct sizing makes a huge difference.

            Cast iron works fine, but neither the barenaked surface nor enameled is very good. Bare loses its seasoning when you deglaze with wine, vinegar or tomato, and enameled the fat runs right through the jus (as James Peterson so ably points out in his classic, "Sauces") I have a large LC roaster and know this to be true. Nonstick is a total disaster for roasting IMO.

            If you make a lot of gravies or integral sauces, I would pick either a SS lining or tinned copper. SS-lined copper may be the ideal construction for a roaster, and would be the only bimetal vessel I would pick over tinned. I don't have issues with aluminum, either bare or anodized, so that would be my second choice.

            It's only on the stovetop that highly conductive roasters shine, so if you don't do much in the way sauces/gravies (or sweat your mirrepoix before roasting), I'd go with a relatively cheap SS pan. For the cost of a single A-C, you can probably find 3 cheaper pans, which allows you to size your pan to the cut/joint and not burn the good stuff.

            Aloha,
            Kaleo

            1. breadchick Sep 26, 2012 04:14 PM

              I have a large Mauviel M'cook roaster for the holidays, and use all my other stuff for smaller roasts during the year: oval LeCreuset bakers, some Emile Henri ceramic ovals, etc. I usually don't make gravies with smaller roasts, so the ceramic works just fine.

              I like the large roaster for Christmas because there's room for a large rib roast and gobs of roasted tatties soaking up all that flavor! (Can't you tell I'm getting antsy for cold weather cooking?)

              For nearly forever I used one of those dependable speckled enamel roasters, but recently switched to the Mauviel because I needed better handles (joint issues) when carrying 20+lb turkeys and I liked the edge for better pouring.

              So, I guess my point is - you have a large choice, good luck!!

              1 Reply
              1. re: breadchick
                l
                lcool Sep 27, 2012 04:47 AM

                AMEN to the wrists,handles and what we handle alone on a regular basis.

              2. j
                jljohn Sep 26, 2012 08:42 PM

                When you refer to the All-Clad roaster, which one do you mean? As I recall, AC makes several different roasters, and they are all only stainless (i.e. NOT tri-ply) except for the Flared Roaster that is sold by Williams Sonoma. I bought one of those last year, and after 2 or 3 uses, the bottom warped so badly that it could rock like a boat and spin like a top on the counter. That's not a good situation! I returned it, and I'm still trying to select one. For the moment, a jelly roll pan serves as a substitute.

                2 Replies
                1. re: jljohn
                  t
                  tapmj Sep 26, 2012 11:46 PM

                  I love love my grandmother's (over 100 years old now) large blue enameled roasting pan.
                  It can hold a 26 lb turkey. I also have her smaller one. I roast veggies, turkeys, beef, ham in it and it is now, as you can imagine, very well seasoned. Just swirl around some EVO and use,
                  with or without lid. You can buy excellent shape pan in a thrift shop for great price.

                  Also love my cast iron skillet. Good luck.

                  1. re: tapmj
                    l
                    lcool Sep 27, 2012 04:43 AM

                    Sounds like you have GRANITE WARE.Great stuff,still being manufactured.

                2. l
                  lcool Sep 27, 2012 04:33 AM

                  Greetings blackbookali

                  I wouldn't recommend any roaster without the foot print,dimensions capable of a LARGE TURKEY (+23#) or a domestic GOOSE ,18" x 10" is the minimum interior/bottom foot print up to the task.Do you anticipate the need for truly large?

                  If your current roaster is too hot on the bottom.Insulate it with a good sheet pan underneath.
                  Problem solved,no more burned aromatics,restaurant answer.

                  kaleokahu's information is excellent,covering all the reasons not to throw $ at this.

                  Large roasters are problematic.What does the damn thing weigh empty?With your 12-30 roast or bird are the ergonomics and weight something you can handle?This is why none stay or have stayed on the market any length of time.Manufacturers are constantly designing and redesigning the human ergonomic thing.This has been true for ? 75 years of large ovens to small ovens now large again.The exception would be GRANITE WARE.After more than 100 years of family cooking,I have some huge pieces,French copper,REGAL WARE aluminium,GRISWOLD and LODGE cast iron and DeBuyer black steel for restaurants as well as big name modern.None of these every remained on the market long,design,weight and storage issues.So if you are seriously considering AllClad or any other current big name,be patient.There are big discounts available every time the design is tweeked.

                  It may not get better than your cast iron skillet,with or without a rack.Why not a larger one?12" to 14" with helper handle?It wouldn't be a one trick pony.Great for baking,round loaves,cornbread,
                  stove top and roasting.

                  1. b
                    blaireso Feb 18, 2013 07:17 PM

                    Sounds like we've all either got the perfect one or are still searching, having gone through several. I'm in this category. I don't want to spend $200 for something used intermittently. For chickens, I've got two really old, unknown metal 9x13 pans I've used for 40 years. They also work for veggies, potatoes, brownies, whatever. (can you bake brownies in CI? probably!) However, they're too small for roasts or turkeys, ribs, etc, react with lasagna type dishes, and are really too thin to spend much time over a burner for sauces. I've also burned two nonstick roasting pans in the last 2 years. The nonstick coating flakes, no matter how gently I wash, soak, etc. IMO forget the nonstick crap--even the expensive ones will eventually degrade. It's a tough issue, to find a moderately priced pan that you can broil, roast, deglaze, bake tomatoey items and convert the jus to sauces. I saw another thread that recommended some aluminum roasters from a restaurant supply store, which I kind of like because you can really get them clean and they season well--but they'll react. I'm in the same boat, I just can't justify $200 in our family budget for something used 3-4 times a year. Different if I was 30, though. Check out Granite Ware and see if you can find a smallish one, 16-18" will hold a fairly good sized roast or bird.

                    Show Hidden Posts