La Cabana, North Fork, CA
Really great gourmet Mexican food. The chef was at Erna's Elderberry House before marrying one of the waitresses and opening his own restaurant in North Fork of all places.
Some unique items on the menu; regular stuff, too, but wonderfully done. Desserts are all made on site and very high-end.
Casual, friendly, inexpensive. Nice outdoor deck. Folks "in the know" come from all over!