Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >
Sep 9, 2012 11:02 PM

When Pigs Fly Cookies?

Has anyone tried these? We are huge fans of WPF breads , and My Love brought home some cookies from the Somerville store the other day. Chocolate, and Peanut Butter (i think) and some 3rd kind. They were each flat and lifeless and as dry as could be. Was my experience a fluke? thx much.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. It's a commercial cookie. I'd opt for a hand made version.

    1. Really? No one else has had these cookies?

      3 Replies
      1. re: opinionatedchef

        I recall getting one once in Coolidge Corner. It was not memorable.

        1. re: Science Chick

          well phooey, sc ! i want them to be consistently brilliant!

          1. re: opinionatedchef

            Recall trying a cookie sample at their flagship store one time the size of a cow pie and it was dry as dirt.

      2. As a comparison, and worth mentioning......I found myself at Iggy's last Friday and purchasing 2 of their cookies. Wow! I wish these were available at off site stores that carry the bread. Are they? I had a couple of the jam-filled almond cookies, and the caramel-filled cocoa cookie. They were buttery, flavorful, not-too-sweet, with an awesome shortbread texture. I may have to make an effort to get to their main store more often.........

        9 Replies
        1. re: Science Chick

          well sc chick, i continue to thank the powers that be- that you post here! Iggy's does introduce new items and i do forget that. I see that we will be out tomorr., stopping there and this Cow and Crumb place i'd never heard of. Chapeaux!

          1. re: opinionatedchef

            Back 'atcha OC! Let me know if you try any of the other cookies they had there. Actually, lots of nice baked goods to try there, aside from their usual wonderful breads. Again, I ask the hounds......does anywhere else sell Iggy's cookies/baked goods?

            1. re: Science Chick

              The pecan sticky buns are fantastic. Haven't seen them anywhere other than their bakery.

            2. re: opinionatedchef

              I looked up Cow and Crumb and couldn't find a storefront listed. It appears they only do mail order. Does anyone know if there is a storefront?

              1. re: catsmeow

                No storefront for C&C. However if you call, I think she can deliver same day around Cambridge or meet you somewhere. Usually they just do mail-order.

                1. re: calvnhobs6

                  hey 6, where did you get yours? or are you on the 'wanna' bus w/ us? (you driving that is!)

                  1. re: opinionatedchef

                    Haha, no I mail ordered them for myself a while back! Enjoy, I know you'll love them. My favorites were the L'orange cookies.

                    1. re: calvnhobs6

                      yes, those were the very ones that pulsed neon when i saw the list of them!

            3. re: Science Chick

              I've never seen the cookies at the farmers markets Iggy's is at. next time I will ask, or demand them!

            4. To be honest, while I occasionally enjoy WPF breads, I've never liked anything else I've had from them, and I have to be in the right mood even for the breads, which are very heavy and not always to my taste. Definitely NOT "consistently brilliant" in my book.

              2 Replies
              1. re: Allstonian

                this. They remind me of the Great Harvest franchise explosion of the 80s: great because my only experience had been wonder bread.

                I put WPF squarely in the "toppings make the pizza great" camp of bread making, whereas I am in the "crust makes the pizza great" school. That camp isn't evil, it's just not my thing. I wouldn't refuse WPF or turn up my nose; I just never, ever, happen to shop there.

                1. re: enhF94

                  Great Harvest?ooooh YIKers,94. In my book, that's like saying Strip T's burger is like McD's. well,with our help, the world does go 'round doesn't it. I comp agree w/ your focus on crust as well as toppings. completely. but I also just love the 'base' (if it is, indeed, a common base) that WPF works from, so packed with flavor, moist density, and interesting combos. I only usually buy the sauerkraut rye and dark rye for myself, but My Love has to have his Harvest. And some of the sweeter ones- Sugared Lemon blueberry raspberry hazelnut, and Chocolate bread- we occas get for french toast.

              2. Not exactly the same thing, but Cow & Crumb bakery in Cambridge does mail-order cookies, although I believe you can arrange for local pick up, and I've definitely seen them around at some farmer's markets. Unbelievably good cookies - much thicker (and more interesting variety) than regular cookies, and they last and stay fresh for a pretty long time. We ordered a bunch for a Christmas party, they were a big hit.

                3 Replies
                1. re: calvnhobs6

                  gee thnx. i never ever heard of them? ! (what's MY problem?) I'll be there tomorrow; thx so much!

                  1. re: calvnhobs6

                    Anyone know what's up with Cow & Crumb? Their webstore has been closed for a few weeks or more.

                    Where else can I get an amazingly rich and buttery and not too sweet shortbread cookie? Or a great shortbread cookie with nuts. The shortbread cookies from Lakota may be the best I've been able to find, and I have been disappointed at countless other bakeries.

                    1. re: azra

                      Ii'm not really a Lakota fan because their icings are confectioners sugar and margerine/crisco iirc, and i believe they do not use 100% butter in their cookies. The Effie's Oatcakes(dave's pasta; whole foods; formaggio) are excellent and shortbread-related. The ____Lark cookies at Formaggio have shortbread-like ingredients but are not sandy. I hate cloyingly sweet cookies so none of the above are super sweet. Vickie Lee Boyajian in Belmont has some good quality products too.