Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Sep 8, 2012 06:36 PM

Good restaurant on Upper West Side for older, conservative eaters?

They liked Coppola which is a straight forward, traditional Italian place which we enjoyed, too. Anyone try Fred's on Amsterdam and 81st? Other ideas?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
      1. re: scarlet knight

        We love Cotta. And while the food there might fit your requirements, I'm not sure the noise level would. It is VERY loud. You could ask for a reservation in the rear room upstairs which is much quieter but it requires stairs - not sure if that's a problem for your group. The menu has both small plates as well as more traditional pastas/entrees. The wines are pretty gently priced and the staff there is usually quite knowledgeable too.

        1. re: scarlet knight

          Recipe is fantastic. Tiny place and not sure if they take reservations, so try to get there early. Portions are not huge, but the food is fresh, delicately prepared, and very tasty. Cotta is also tasty, but agree re: the noise level (as mentioned above). Fred's is a great place too, but different - it's more bar/comfort food. There are seats at the bar and a few tables in front and then a pretty big dining room in the back, which is nice and cozy - really friendly service and great food (burgers, mac and cheese, etc), but more casual than the other places.

      2. Perhaps Scaletta, on 77th between Columbus and CPW. They've been there forever, good classic Italian and quiet, nicely spaced tables. Definitely attracts an older crowd and has a menu of old standards.

        3 Replies
        1. re: City Kid

          second Scaletta. An obvious choice if you liked Coppola and want nice food and quiet

          1. re: alc

            Telepan at 69th bet. Broadway and Columbus.
            La Boite en Bois at 68th between Broadway and Columbus, reminiscent of a charming, small Parisian walk-down.

            1. re: arepo

              Have eaten at both. Both very good. May try Scaletta first with this group.

        2. We love Fred's but it's not a place that fits what you want. Early in the evening nearly every table has at least one kid. Later, it's mostly people in their 30s. Good, friendly neighborhood place with decent food at reasonable prices. But I don't think it's what you want.

          What's your budget?

          3 Replies
          1. re: plf515

            Budget is moderate. Dovetail is too expensive and experimental. We like Telepan , but that might be more costly than we like for this group. Scaletta is the leading cadidate, but I welcome other nominees.

            1. re: scarlet knight

              La Mirabelle is a comfortable place for an older, conservative group.

              1. re: americanafan

                mirabelle is perfect for this genre, but it is fairly expensive (less than Telepan or Ouest, however).

          2. We really enjoyed The Leopard at des Artistes on 67th St between W Central Park & Columbus Ave on a recent visit. It might be a little pricier than what you are looking for but the service and meal were impeccable. Beautiful decor and atmosphere. We are older and pretty conservative when it comes to dining and it was the highlight restaurant of our trip.