HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >


Making those vinegary marinated big white beans you see in deli or olive bar

At an olive bar and at an Italian deli I've seen these big white beans (not sure if they're cannellini's or other variety) that are in an oily and acidic (vinegary) marinade with what looks like roasted sweet peppers and other herbs and aromatics. I think they are always served cold.

I don't know what this is called, and I'm not quite sure how to reproduce this at home. My son LOVES these and I'd like to figure out how to reproduce these at home instead of buying them.

Thanks in advance!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. You think you are referring to gigantes?

    1 Reply
    1. re: rasputina

      I have seen "gigantes" that look like the big white beans, but I've only seen them jarred at Trader Joe's in some sort of red-sauce. So perhaps the same bean, but much different preparation.

    2. Are you thinking of lupini?

      If so, a good prep/primer is here.


      4 Replies
      1. re: pinehurst

        Nah, those aren't it... they look more like giant cannellini beans that have been dressed/marinated with some herbs and bits of sweet pepper.

          1. re: pinehurst

            Hmmm... the lima beans I'm familiar with (Christmas lima's) are dark colored, purple-ish, but this actually seems to resemble it pretty closely, thank you!

            1. re: nasv

              No,. Christmas lima beans are actually not a common variety in markets. "Lima" translates as "bean", which is why we use lima bean as the name for several varieties.
              What you want is NOT the pale green, fairly flat bean sold frozen, canned, and as part of succotash. Look instead at what is sold in cans as "butter beans". They are larger, buttery in color, and milder in flavor than the smaller, green lima. If buying the dry version of butter beans, you want "large dry lima beans". Most supermarkets sell them alongside the bagged lentils and split peas. There's also a small dry lima bean, which is the same off-white color, and similar in flavor to the large so I don't think it's the dried version of the green lima. The butter/dried large lima bean tastes the same as the gigantes, to me, but is a lot cheaper and easier to find. You need to soak the dried beans and cook gently if you want to avoid the skins coming off entirely. Some people like to remove them, however. When trying to duplicate the deli item, I'd use the canned version so I didn't have to fuss over the texture. Once I had the other ingredients worked out, I'd go back and figure out how to combine them with limas I cooked at home.

      2. I think what you are referring to are actually Fava Beans. You are starting to see them more and more in the U.S. in the produce dept.

        1 Reply
        1. re: robt5265

          No, not favas, I'm familiar with fresh and dried favas. The ones I'm thinking more closely resemble cannellini beans or bigger. I think they could be the "gigantes" mentioned earlier.

        2. I know the salad you mean, and it's good. I've never made it from a recipe, but this looks close:

          4 Replies
            1. re: Whippet

              I made this recently and while it was OK, it was nowhere near as good as the stuff from the Whole Foods antipasto bar. I even added some roasted red peppers for extra flavor, but still meh.

              Also, when I soaked the beans overnight, they practically exploded, splitting at the seams to the point where they looked ghastly. Oddly, after cooking they came back together somewhat, but still didn't have that firm creaminess of the store-bought. Maybe they were too old? How can you tell if beans are too old when you buy them?

              1. re: BobB

                Somewhere on the bag, often hard to find (it may be on the seam, is a date. Old beans are still usable but if you need them to cook perfectly, try to use them by their best by date.

                1. re: BobB

                  I was gifted a bag of rancho gordo beans a long time ago and it changed everything.... Using "heirloom beans", or some from a local farm makes a huge huge difference for simple bean dishes like this one.
                  In that recipe linked i would have added some garlic to the marinade as well as adding fresh lemon juice just before serving- IMO green bell peppers have no place here, your use of the roasted red pepper is a good idea.

              2. They are called fagioli di Spagna in Italian and are pretty much the same as gigantes. Also called white Spanish beans in English. As for making the salad, you're on your own, but I agree, it's a great dish.

                1. Yes, those are gigantes, or gigandes. Once you find a source (try online? I get mine from a local italian/greek deli and they're about $6/12 oz bag. Ouch.), soak overnight, bring to a boil in lots of water on top of stove, skim, add a bay leaf and whatever else you want, then BAKE @ 350, don't simmer stovetop. It's much more gentle, beans don't break up. I salt the water about halfway through, and check occasionally to be sure the beans are still covered in water. If not, top up (they absorb a lot of water). When they're done, let cool to lukewarm in the liquid, which also helps prevent them from breaking, drain, add to a vinaigrette flavored however you want (garlic and herbs for me, good vinegar and oil), along w. the roasted peppers you like. I like to add chopped pickled peppers, as in pickled cherry peppers or peppadews. Let cool completely, taste again for seasoning, eat happily. Hope this helps.

                  3 Replies
                    1. re: noeldottir

                      I will try this except it seems like I taste a little lemon juice when I eat these so I am going to add that. Glad to hear they can be made from the dried beans as I plan on Growing them this year.

                    2. Could they be butter beans? I use them in a cold salad with parsley, oil and vinegar/lemon, salt, pepper, and sometimes some tomato or red bell pepper.

                      1. How did the recipe work out and which beans did you use?

                        1. Did some googling and found these:

                          With shipping they're about $30 for a 2 kg can (that's about 4-1/2 lbs for you non-metrics), compared to about $10/pint at Whole Foods, and their reviews say they're just like the antipasto bar beans, AND they freeze well. I've ordered a can, I'll let you know how they are.

                          2 Replies
                          1. re: BobB

                            And a bit of further checking reveals that Walmart also sells them - but only by the six-pack (yes, that's six 2 kg cans!) The good news is, they sell them for $17.50 per can and don't charge for shipping, so if they turn out to be the real thing, I'll probably do that in future - in cans they'll keep indefinitely, so it's just a question of finding storage space (hey, what's a basement for, eh?)

                            The weird thing is, Amazon and Walmart appear to be the only places on the entire Web (other than wholesale-only sites) where you can buy these.

                            1. re: BobB

                              And the verdict is: these Divina beans are not LIKE the ones they sell at Whole Foods, they ARE the ones they sell at Whole Foods. I've found the source! Too bad the OP hasn't been back on the site in a while. I'll be buying these regularly from now on.