HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >

Discussion

Steel or glass electric kettle?

After reading through a couple of threads about electric kettles, I am still unsure as to which brand to buy. I have an aversion to plastic touching my food. I notice that some of the ones I've seen have what I think is silicone or plastic sealant. Do silicone emit anything into the water (or whatever that mystery sealant is.)

I want a high quality electric kettle and cannot decide between glass or stainless steel. I've seen the Cuisinart stainless steel electric kette, the Salton glass electric kettle and mentions of the Krups brand.

I've even considered those eternal hot water dispenser that are seen in many Asian homes but all of them have "sticky outy" elements in them.

I want a clean-lined interior with no visible heating element inside.

Can someone suggest a brand that they have used for a good length of time with little trouble?

Glass or steel?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. I"m on my second Capresso glass electric kettle. I've been really happy with them(I'm on my second because I gave my first to my sister...that one has been getting daily use for 2-3 years now).
    http://www.amazon.com/Capresso-259-03...

    2 Replies
    1. re: ziggylu

      I've seen reviews on Amazon about a foul chemical smell with the Capresso. In fact, about half the reviews were negative about this kettle. I really do like the glass kettle but worry about any off smell.

      1. re: maxmillan

        Huh. I haven't had any issue with mine. I boiled it full a few time and watered the plants with the water before using it for my tea.

        I worked in a kitchen store for several years. the most popular kettles were this Capresso and the Breville with the temperature control. We saw few returns on either.

        Before the Capresso I'd bought a Pino. Avoid at all costs. Didn't even last a year and only had a 90 day warranty.

        .

    2. http://www.zojirushi.com/products/cdlcc

      The Zojirushi Panorama Window™ Micom Electric Dispensing Pot has served me well for several years. It always has plenty of hot water ready to go. Mine has some sort of liner though for hard water deposits so, if you are concerned with coatings it may not be the best choice for you.

      In terms of health and safety, silicone is used in a lot of cooking applications. I'm not aware of any adverse health effects. Plastics used in the food industry are put through pretty rigorous tests before they are released to the public in commercial channels. With the poor air quality most people see on a daily basis, food grade plastics are pretty low on my list of things I'm conerned about.

      1. The Cuisinart electric stainless steel kettle has served our kitchen admirably for several years, day in and day out, several times a day.

        2 Replies
        1. re: Michael Rodriguez

          I had a Capresso and experienced the same nasty-smell problem. I liked the design so much I kept it, but when it finally broke, I replaced it with something else.

          What I have now is an inexpensive Chinese-made kettle (Boni) which is all stainless steel on the inside. Has worked fine for 2 years now, no bells or whistles, just comes to a boil and turns itself off. It has a nice long pour spout, good for finicky tea-making. The stainless steel ain't perfect; there are a couple of discolored spots on the inside, but it hasn't bugged me.

          Next time I'll probably spring for a Taiwanese-made one. I've seen them, same nice shape but probably better quality and more $$,

          1. re: comestible

            Old thread, but this is just an update to my post above. The Chinese (Boni) kettle I wrote about broke the other day. The tab that switches it on and off simply broke from its moorings when I turned it on. That gives it a 3-1/2 year lifespan. But I note that it got a lot of use, several heat-ups per day.

            It would be interesting to compare how long other kettles last.

            Anyway, I went to Chinatown and bought another, same brand but a bit smaller. Set me back $23.

        2. Thanks for your input. I forgot about the Chinese hardware stores. They usually have a lot of kitchen appliances. Maybe if I wait a bit longer, someone will get me the Breville for my birthday! I will also give the Capresso a fair shake but I'll have to buy it from a source with a good return policy should it give an off-smell.

          1. I've narrowed it down to the electric Cuisinart glass tea/kettle and the Breville stainless steel kettle. Now for those Christmas specials.

            1. Probably little or no practical value to a current shopper unless you are looking on eBay, but my 25 year old plus Russell Hobbs rocks. Daily use the whole while.

              1. Glass kettles can look very grotty/cruddy quite quickly.

                1. I still haven't bought an electric kettle yet. Still haven't found one with no plastic and I'm steering away from glass because I've seen too many reviews about it leaking.

                  So what is the forum's opinion about boiling water in an electric coffee percolater? I found an all stainless steel one without any plastic level indicator.

                  1. I'm going with steel, I can tell you why i didn't go with the glass. Basically because of the many times i have read about "leaking" that did it for me.

                    Everything you listed that you want in an electric tea kettle is everything i am searching for. I am leaning towards Hamilton because of the reviews on Amazon No BPA. The best comments i heard was about the NO Smell, bonus in my book. Check it out, i think im going to try it out, what the heck, it's only $27. If it doesn't work then i'm only out $27 basically.
                    http://www.amazon.com/Hamilton-Beach-...

                    I also was thinking of Chef's choice, which gets really high reviews.

                    And another choice is Amora
                    http://www.amazon.com/Aroma-AWK-115S-...

                    Look forward to hearing what you chose, good luck

                    1 Reply
                    1. re: vsadler

                      Okay, after still reading many reviews i found the one i wanted and bought it from Amazon today.
                      Read this review, i found it most helpful to make my decision.
                      http://www.ineedcoffee.com/09/electri...

                      I went with the Hamilton Beach Cool Touch, here is the link, check it out.
                      http://www.amazon.com/Hamilton-Beach-...

                      Pretty good deal too. Will be back after a few months and give you my review. :)