Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Jul 31, 2012 06:16 AM

Post-Yankee game meal options?

Looking for a good place in Manhattan for an after game meal. We won't be dressed for business but still want as top-shelf a meal as possible. Thinking of a churriscaria but open to most other options. We will be driving but one guy will be taking the train back to CT so quick access afterwards is a plus.

I'll leave a report afterwards. thanks again.....Nick

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. How many people in your party?

    When is this meal? Early or late? Are you planning way in advance or for in a few days?

    What's your budget?

    For a casual ish, meat heavy guys night out, it sounds like you'd do well at Minetta Tavern. Maybe Takashi. I highly recommend making a reservation for either.

    8 Replies
    1. re: kathryn

      4. Its an afternoon game so anytime after 5pm. Tomorrow. Unlimited.

      Both restaurants look appetizing but oh so far south. Anything closer between Midtown and the Bronx?

        1. re: RGR

          Keens is cool with Yankee jerseys and shorts?

          1. re: pktaske

            I don't imagine that would be a problem, but you can call the restaurant to check.

            Hill Country BBQ is a bit south of Midtown. Definitely no problem with jerseys and shorts there. For your friend returning to CT, two stops on the nearby 6 train to Grand Central.


            1. re: RGR

              Back from Keens. Not good. Wrote them an email and will follow up with group on details and their response.

              1. re: pktaske

                "Everything was good except the main meal. Steak (NYS) was tough and flavouless [sic]."

                That's your comment on the Wolfgang vs. Keens thread.

                Did you tell your waiter and request a replacement? I can understand writing an emal if a restaurant refuses to address a problem Did you give them the chance to do so?


                1. re: RGR

                  Keens is the last place I'd bother speaking to a manager. What for? So they can tell you their reputation, and claim nobody has sent a steak back before? Best to just send the food back and leave.

      1. re: kathryn

        UPDATE -

        The bad news: Did not have a great meal at Keens last night. More specifically, did not have a great steak. Pretty much everything else about the night was spot on excepting the fact that all of our NY strips (3 to be exact) , while ample and cooked perfectly, were tough. Of course, this was more than disappointing.

        The good news: While I do not make a habit of it (in fact, never in my dining life), I wrote a short email this morning to the Keens staff. I received a call from them about 8 minutes later professionally apologizing and making amends. What a pleasant experience. Many other establishments of thier ilk should learn from them.

      2. How about Mickey Mantle's on Central Park South to stay in a Bronx Bomber mood?

        2 Replies
        1. re: Motosport

          Mickey Mantle's has closed. In any case, you're a day late. He went to Keens.

          1. re: RGR

            OOPS! I've never been there but always wanted to go. Such is life! A dollar short and a day late.
            Go Yankees!

        2. I read through the whole thread, but for future reference, I often go straight to Chinatown after Yankees games, though those are usually night games. The D zips pretty quickly to Grand St., which is close to NY Noodletown. Not a place for steak, but their roast duck is excellent.