Legal Harborside 2nd floor
Probably too late for the birthday you asked this about, but hopefully you'll be having another birthday this year.
We went there on Saturday for my mom's b-day. Definitely a more expensive outing that we are accustomed to, but we were 100% pleased. From the friendly valet to the great table (by the window) to the helpful waiter to the visits from the GM or manager, the service could not have been better.
The food was excellent. Didn't think you could improve upon the homarus americanus, but smoking it for a couple of hours made it amazing (and even better, cold, the next morning). I had the "Tomahawk steak", which was described to me as "a petite 32 ounce cut". It was basically the Flintstones cut, with the bone sticking off the plate, and was cooked perfectly. Big enough that I had a great lunch on Sunday after heating it for a few minutes in a frying pan.
They knew it was mom's b-day, so comped one the shared dessert we had, and wrote "Happy birthday" in dark chocolate on the plate. Even brought over a card signed by the waiter, maitre'd, and someone else as a final touch.