My FI and I are throwing our own enagement party and are looking for great food preferebaly Italian. We are on a budget ( 40-50 pp) for 65 people. BYOB would be great. We havent had any luck. nothing too casual. would love some help!
LouCas in Edision close to the Garden State Parkway is a very highly regarded BYOB. You can do any number of searches on this board for reviews and feedback. I'm pretty sure they are within your price range and have a private room downstairs. Good luck !!