Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >
Jul 18, 2012 05:56 PM

TRAGIC: Has the BANANA CREAM PIE @APPLE PAN really changed??

Went to apple pan last night after failing to try the bacon banana cream pie @a-frame (twas taken off menu just days prior). As soon as the slices were set before us, I turned to my friend in reluctant disbelief and asked why it looked so different. The slices were perfectly cut with a perfect, thick layer of whipped cream on top. There was hardly any custard, and plenty more bananas than I remember the pies always containing. Of course one never should judge by appearance alone so I took the first trepid bite, only to have my fears be confirmed: the glorious standby that was apple pan's bc pie had surely been altered....and not for betterment. Too many bananas, not enough custard...bananas apparently peeled and sliced before they were even ripe (a gigantuous NO in any banana dessert). The crust was off, both texturally and taste-wise. All the times I'd had it prior, the pie was more of a messy scoop of custard, bananas, broken crust and a dollop of whipped cream...not this perfectly sliced pie abomination. I picked at it with my fork a couple more times before surrendering it (gladly) to my friend who wholly agreed with me but will eat anything rather than waste it. I, for one, would rather have had pie-n-burger or bake-n-broil's bc pie before me...heck, even marie callendar's. :/

I asked our waiter if they had changed the recipe for the bc pie but he shook his head defiantly and said "no...same pastry chef, same pie." To be honest, it had been more than 2 years since I'd had it last but I know this travesty was not due to some error in my memory. I've had the darn pie countless times in the past and it had always been absolutely delish....not in some decadent way with chocolate shavings and caramel swirls, or bacon bits, but in the way a simple, homey but spot-on banana cream pie should be.

As my friend confirmed the horrid change, I know I'm not talking or thinking crazy here. Has anyone else experienced this or could it possibly have been a fluke? It's difficult when the waiter denies it but the alterations are really undeniable. Please help!! I want my banana cream pie back!!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Uh oh. Now I gotta go see for myself...

    1. The original comment has been removed
      1. Apple Pan's Yelp page has pictures of various food items, including several of banana cream pie slices uploaded in 2010. Take a look and see how they compare to what you had today. As far as structure, I've had neatly cut slices and sloppy ones, depending more on the skill of the pie cutter than anything else.

        I haven't had bcp at Apple Pan for several years now, but in my fuzzy recollection, it didn't have a TON of custard, and was more about the fruit.

        2 Replies
        1. re: Jack Flash

          Every time I've had it previously the custard to banana ratio was great. I don't prefer a TON of custard, however, this pie had just BARELY ENOUGH to hold the bananas together. The pie crust did not taste all that great and it was not densely flaky. The gravest error, though, was the banana being unripened. :x

          1. re: namstermonster

            The unripe banana is indeed an unforgivable sin. And there's no excuse for a substandard crust.

            As I said, I haven't had it often enough (or recently enough) to say with any real conviction what the custard:banana ratio has been. I did look at several pictures of the pie, though, and for the most part they looked to be mostly fruit (and this applies to pictures that go back at least to 2010). However, I will say that my initial memory (which could be extremely faulty) is more in line with yours (i.e., a lot more custard), but I'm not really willing to trust my memory on this one.

        2. OK, reporting back...

          I gotta say, the banana cream pie is pretty much the same as I remember it to be... "Sloppy" slicing, same banana-to-custard ratio, a generous dollop of whipped cream on top, flaky crust, and the bananas used were riperiperipe. Here are 2 photos...

          4 Replies
          1. re: J.L.

            Now you're just being cruel and torturing me with those food porn photos...and if you call that a "dollop" of whipped cream then I'd hate to see what your definition of a copious amount would be... ;-D>

            1. re: Servorg

              Hey, I'm actually showing restraint by not posting photos of our delicious hickoryburger & steakburger, and of course the apple pie a la mode...


            2. re: J.L.

              Hrmm…perhaps it was just a fluke that day as well as once a few months ago when my BF went (she also did not like it). I’ll have to make another trek very soon, with my fingers crossed!! Thanks, JL.

              1. re: namstermonster

                I too hope your experience was just a fluke. Fingered crossed for you!