It's been a while and we are big fans of Snapper's, Island Grill, Morada Bay, and a few other waterfront spots whose names escape me. Any must eats or drinks in Islamorada to check out right now?
I had a bad experience at Made to Order last year...It was very warm outside and it took at least 40 minutes to get our simple breakfast order. Those kind of things really put me off.. I will never go back just because of that. I may be jumping the gun ...BUT... I give one chance and that is it.
I just got back from the keys yesterday... Here is a short critique.
I was with my spouse and my 10 year old grandson. First day we stopped at Snappers in Tavernier... $17 for a so-so Ceviche and a so-so fish sandwich. My grandson wanted a burger Sunday night... We went to Chilli Willies to get the burger....To my suprise the food was quite good.. I had 10 very good wings and my grandson and spouse had burgers.....They were both pleasantly surprised ,and the prices were reasonable... Looks like a place you wouldn't expect in the keys but was quite good.
Last night we stopped at Mandalay Bay at MM97.5....Everything was very good. Had the calamari app and fish tacos. It was way to warm outside to do the Lorelei waterfront .
For a quickie burger I would rec. Chilli Willies... Never thought I would say that ,but it is true
I think food and service in the Keys can be more hit and miss than normal in other areas... due to the super laid-back aspect.
I also suspect it's hard for chefs to maintain high enthusiasm in largely tourist locales.
My sister has been in the restaurant industry down there for over 25 years.
She says: "If an employee simply shows up for work on any given day, that's considered a pretty good start."
I am so glad you told me about chili willie's because every time we pass it, I comment and say I wonder how that place is! Good to know! We had lunches at Islamorada Fish Co., Lorelai and Morada Bay. Best food of the three was Morada Bay but all in all it's pretty much the same fish and fish sandwich, I think. Agree with you on Snapper's too.
My big gripe with the Keys, or Islamorada at least, is that they all stop serving breakfast (except Islamorada Bakery in which I found a hair in my hash browns, so see ya never again to that one) at 11. For a tourist-driven place that's supposed to be on its own slow time clock, why not serve breakfast at least until noon?! Especially on weekends. Oh well.
Island Grill has a terrible breakfast buffet with overcooked food.
A good breakfast spot for a change was Key Largo Conch House. Good Cajun Omelet.
Anyone been to the Green Turtle lately?
My favorite place in the Upper Keys now is Tasters Grill in the Tavernier Town shopping center (in the back near the movie theater).
I think it is technically just north of Islamorada, but close enough. Not a typical Keys menu -- but with a few Keys standards. The food is very interesting and very good. You wouldn't know it when you enter the center or the restaurant, but there is waterfront seating in the back too and they have had craft beer tastings back there when I have been there. Definitely worth checking out.
I will soon be spending 3 nights in Islamorada and am wondering if there are any updates to this thread. Particularly interested in dinner places offering local fish and seafood, but will eat almost anything. Food is more important than the decor or setting and would prefer to avoid restaurants featuring overworked "fancy" dishes. To give an idea of what I've liked in South Florida in the 2 weeks plus that I've been here: Max's Harvest, in Delray, and Yardbird in Miami Beach.
Also, any additional suggestions for simple breakfasts with good bread in Islamorada?
Will take a day trip to Key West one day, so looking for fresh, simple lunch spot. (Paseo looks good, but does not seem to be open during our days there, Monday/Tuesday) What about BO Fish Wagon? Other ideas?
I was just down there for New Years weekend. We were at family events so did not dine out much.
But my hotel was right near a place that caught my eye:
Peace, Love and Hogfish
I have no idea if it is any good. But you've got to give them credit for a great tagline! I would definitely want to at least investigate such a place.
PS: A quick look elsewhere on the net shows a lot of highly favorable reviews.
I haven't eaten there in a very long time....but Bentley's in Islamorada was very, very good....and for a very long time.....Ziggy and Mad Dog's has been an Islamorada favorite.....as is The Lorelai.....especially on a Sunday afternoon.....
Ft. Pierce, FL