HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
What's your latest food quest? Get great advice

Artie's or Barney Greengrass?

lemarais Jun 28, 2012 04:58 PM

Will be on the UWS and want to know which one would be preferred for a good pastrami sandwich-- and do they make their own cole slaw? Or is there a 3rd choice?

Also, how is the herring at Murray's Sturgeon?

  1. a
    AubWah Jun 28, 2012 05:59 PM

    For Pastrami, just go to Katz's. For smoked fish, go to the Sturgeon King

    1. a
      alc Jun 28, 2012 07:24 PM

      Check out Menu Pages. I don't know if Barney G serves pastrami; I think of it as a dairy place. The other two choices for sit-down places of that style on the UWS are Fine & Shapiro and Lansky's. I can't speak to the comparative quality of the pastrami, however.

      1 Reply
      1. re: alc
        coasts Jun 29, 2012 08:58 PM

        Fine and Shapiro is terrible. nothing redeeming to be found there.

      2. r
        r32nissan Jun 28, 2012 07:40 PM

        I've had the Pastrami from Arties and it is very good for the UWS. However, I agree with AubWah - just head to Katz's if you can swing it.

        I'm pretty sure Barney Greengrass has pastrami, I've never had it so cannot speak to it, but I will highly recommend their whitefish salad, chopped liver and eggs, lox and onions.

        1. l
          lemarais Jun 28, 2012 08:33 PM

          I'm just going to be on the UWS, so Katz is out. Looks like B Greengrass is dairy-- do they have good herring? What about Murray's for herring? Is Artie's the best pastrami on the UWS?

          Where is Sturgeon King? Not in google...

          3 Replies
          1. re: lemarais
            alc Jun 28, 2012 08:56 PM

            I think that Barny G advertises itself as the "Sturgeon King." I don't think Murray's has seating. I haven't eaten smoked fish in years so I can't speak to it but BG has always had the reputation for being tops for smoked fish. Back when I did eat such meals I very much enjoyed the scrambled eggs with nova at BG. Some find the decor a bit faded and old fashioned.

            1. re: alc
              rteplow Jun 29, 2012 05:41 AM

              I recommend Barney Greengrass! It's been around for years and is still great. I can't speak for the pastrami, but the fish is great, and I also love the glass of borscht with sour cream.

              Murray's Sturgeon is very good too, but there is no place to sit. You could take out and have a picnic. Artie's is OK but I much prefer the other two places.

            2. re: lemarais
              Wilfrid Jun 28, 2012 09:17 PM

              Barney Greengrass IS the sturgeon king, and it is not dairy. It serves pastrami and other meat sandwiches.

              Crazy to go to Barney Greengrass, which specializes in smoked fish and other appetizings, to eat a pastrami sandwich. If you're going to be on the UWS, eat what's good there.

              I've never eaten Artie's pastrami, just because I've never heard it suggested it's among the best in the city.

            3. p
              Pan Jun 29, 2012 12:20 AM

              I have never had a pastrami sandwich at Barney Greengrass and never expect to, but I find Artie's pastrami insipid and not really too worthwhile, whereas Greengrass has great lox, sturgeon, and whitefish! I love their scrambled eggs with lox for breakfast.

              1. l
                lemarais Jun 29, 2012 04:01 PM

                What's the best place for herring? Do they cut it up to order or is it prepackaged (a la Zabar's)?

                1 Reply
                1. re: lemarais
                  alc Jun 29, 2012 04:17 PM

                  Barney Greengrass is a restaurant where they served smoked fish and herring on plates like any other restaurant. They also have a take out section where they will package things.

                  If you want herring the place is Aquavit on the east side.

                2. MOREKASHA Jul 1, 2012 05:15 AM

                  Barney Greengrass is THE place to go for fish where you can eat it there (sit down). Take away (fish) you have the holy UWS Trinity, BG, Zabars and Murray s. As for Artie's, it's a fucking theme place, it sucks.If in doubt @ BG get a combo or just splurge.

                  Show Hidden Posts