HOME > Chowhound > New Orleans >

which should I eliminate?

n
ncara Jun 17, 2012 07:41 PM

So far we have lunches planned at August and Herbsaint and dinners at GW Fins, R'evolution and Dantes...we need to eliminate 1 of the 5...which should it be????

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. s
    sanglier RE: ncara Jun 17, 2012 08:37 PM

    I've never eliminated Herbsaint from ANYTHING! But with the 5 you laid out, I'd nix Herbsaint IF you're going for lunch, which is not nearly as good as dinner there. I only favor an August lunch for the price advantage vs. their dinner prices. I go to Herbsaint for dinner for almost all special occasions, my favorite overall restaurant here.

    1. s
      Seige RE: ncara Jun 17, 2012 09:16 PM

      Do NOT eliminate R'evolution. I had a somewhat m'eh dinner at August with some issues, but haven't been there for lunch. I've not been to the other places, but again, don't eliminate R'evolution.

      1. noradeirdre RE: ncara Jun 18, 2012 06:27 AM

        I'd eliminate GW Fins. But take with grain of salt, I haven't been there. But I love Herbsaint and August (for lunch) and Dante's, and R'evolution is at the top of my list to go to.

        3 Replies
        1. re: noradeirdre
          Bill Hunt RE: noradeirdre Jun 18, 2012 07:49 PM

          Hm-m, local seafood (mostly), done with local preps. Why would you eliminate them?

          Just curious,

          Hunt

          1. re: noradeirdre
            j
            JazzyB RE: noradeirdre Jun 19, 2012 06:04 AM

            Dined at GWFins a couple weeks ago. Fabulous meal. Two of us shared 5 apps and split the Scalibut entree (a must). Many love Dantes. I am not a fan. Nothing bad, nothing great. Best entree is the chicken under a brick, infused with a wonderful maple flavor. Unfortunately it falls short due to soft skin.

            Have lunch at Commander's (in the garden room) instead of Herbsaint (better for dinner).

            1. re: noradeirdre
              p
              Plano Rose RE: noradeirdre Jun 19, 2012 02:40 PM

              We've been to New Orleans many times and lived there for two years. GW Fins on our last trip was probably the best food we've ever eaten there

            2. p
              Paranatural RE: ncara Jun 18, 2012 07:58 AM

              GW Finn's or August, I think.

              1 Reply
              1. re: Paranatural
                Bill Hunt RE: Paranatural Jun 18, 2012 07:49 PM

                Why?

                Hunt

              2. N.O.Food RE: ncara Jun 18, 2012 05:25 PM

                I'd drop fins. Dante's will get you out of the quarter.

                6 Replies
                1. re: N.O.Food
                  Bill Hunt RE: N.O.Food Jun 18, 2012 07:51 PM

                  Dante's IS good, but does one need to "get out of the Quarter," when dining?

                  Just wonder why the choice.

                  Hunt

                  1. re: Bill Hunt
                    i
                    irked RE: Bill Hunt Jun 19, 2012 06:15 AM

                    If you're sticking to fine dining, the Quarter should keep you full of good food. If you want some cheap eats, the Quarter sucks.
                    Bottom line is that any excuse to get outside of the most touristy area of any city should be reason enough. New Orleans is small enough to get a feel for the whole city with just a few days' stay. There's so much more than t-shirt shops, big ass drinks in silly containers and old classic restaurants.

                    1. re: irked
                      j
                      JazzyB RE: irked Jun 19, 2012 06:30 AM

                      Every visitor should take a ride on both the St. Charles and Canal streetcars for a glimpse of what lies beyond the quarter.

                      1. re: irked
                        uptownlibrarian RE: irked Jun 19, 2012 07:35 AM

                        To be fair, there's much more to the French Quarter than t-shirt shops, big ass drinks, and classic restaurants too. That's a fairly reductive description. I disagree that the Quarter sucks for cheap eats too. There are plenty of options, and several cheap eats threads in the past year have explored them. Of course I agree that it's great to get out of the Quarter whenever possible, but it doesn't have to be either/or.

                        1. re: irked
                          Bill Hunt RE: irked Jun 19, 2012 05:44 PM

                          Good point, and one that I had not fully considered.

                          Thanks,

                          Hunt

                          1. re: irked
                            k
                            kibbles RE: irked Jul 3, 2012 12:27 PM

                            tons of cheap eats in the quarter. too many to list... from $3.00 bahn mi (from real vietnamese to boo), to the daytime poboy shops, to the numerous late nite delis & diners. too many to list.

                            the beauty of the quarter is it scales very well. if you want Big Ass Drinks, you can have that. if you want cheap eats, you can have that. if you want excellent fine dining -- both at old classics, or new -- you can have that too.

                      2. i
                        irked RE: ncara Jun 19, 2012 06:10 AM

                        Tough call!
                        I haven't been to R'evolution yet. Of the other four, I would drop Herbsaint simply for the same reason as sanglier gave - better for dinner.

                        1. N.O.Food RE: ncara Jun 19, 2012 06:36 PM

                          To be clear, I'm not knocking Fins. It's great. But I would drop it in order to get to a different part of town. I also don't think it's as good as Revolution, August, or Herbsaint.

                          1 Reply
                          1. re: N.O.Food
                            Bill Hunt RE: N.O.Food Jun 21, 2012 07:16 PM

                            I have not been to R'evolution yet, but it is a totally different restaurant, than August, or Herbsaint - yet great for local seafood with local prep - hence my suggestion to keep it.

                            Hunt

                          2. n
                            ncara RE: ncara Jul 2, 2012 04:05 PM

                            My decision was made for me....just got a call from August that they have to cancel my reservation for September because they will be closed for 2 weeks for maintenance.

                            Show Hidden Posts