Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
May 29, 2012 11:00 AM

a place with the most intersting "not traditional" cupcakes ?

I don't like cupcakes, but i would like to add one special place to the list for next visit -
are there places that has outrageously good and especially "out of the box combinations"
but not too sugary flavours ? Maybe places that lean more towards the use of dark chocolate, citrus (like any good yuzu or mayer lemon "infused" cupcakes?), berries, fruits cremes, yougurt etc? Not interested in cupcakes that use the more sugary chocolates, peanut creme etc..

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I'd recommend Butch Bakery but they are closed until the fall.

    How about Kyotofu?

    1. I think you will have a hard time overall finding what you're looking for because cupcakes are often all about nostalgia -- sugar bombs with frosting piled high. If you don't like cupcakes at all, you might still be disappointed.

      That said, I think the Asian inspired ones such as Kyotofu or Spot. Maybe Chikalicious.

      Kee's Chocolates used to make what you are looking for but that was a few years ago. I don't know if they are still doing it. She used to do juniper, earl grey, yuzu, etc.

      4 Replies
      1. re: kathryn

        Agreed with Kathryn and I would add in Everything Frosted in Chinatown to the list. They have flavors like Jasmine Tea & Lemon and aren't very sweet at all.

        1. re: roze

          Thanks LG, Kathryn and Roze, i may need to try and do a crawl of some of Chinatown bakeries, so that might be a good idea to try also special cupcakes..
          Kathrin thx for the notice on Kee - my last visit was a couple of years ago and i understand that now she also sells macarons, which also is not my "cup of tea" when the wonderful chocolates are around. But if they still do there cupcakes - for sure i will have a couple to try.

            1. re: Riverman500

              I like Takahachi bakery for its Maron pie pastry ( chestnut), also for yuzu tart and even its sandwiches. For cupcakes, Billy's also in Tribeca is amazing. I especially like their banana cupcakes and pumpkin cupcakes.

        1. re: thegforceny

          Thanks, i liked their "past flavors" section, a lot of interesting stuff that i may even "steal" for ice cream flavor combinations at home "-) If i will be in the area, will check the place.. Thx !

          1. re: thegforceny

            Robicellis was also my first choice. They update their tumblr with distributors in Manhattan so you can always check to see if the flavors you want are nearby.

          2. I recently sampled alcohol infused cupcakes from Prohibition Bakery while at the Hester Street Fair a week or so ago. ( The Pretzels & Beer cupcake and Sangria cupcake really tasted like their namesakes. I don't believe that they have a storefront yet, but if you happen to be in town during the Hester Street Fair it's worth a stop. Otherwise, order information is on their website.