Dell'Anima vs Hearth which is better for a vegetarian?

[Missmoo]

Figuring out our last meal in NY and wondering if one is better than the other? Three of us eat meat, two do not.

Thanks!

[kathryn]

I assume you're eating on a Monday, like you posted previously? So really you're comparing Dell'anima's Meatless Monday with Hearth's regular menu?
http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/843418
http://chowhound.chow.com/topics/844688

Why did you decide against Scarpetta or Ciano, which others suggested?

I've not done Meatless Monday at Dell'anima (just other days of the week), the food is excellent.

I have taken vegetarians to Hearth who were quite pleased. The food doesn't feel super Italian to me, though.

[Missmoo]

I had decided on Meatless Monday at Dell'anima, because Ciano which I was most interested in seemed too meaty (unless they did the tasting menu). Thanks for the notice (about Hearth not being very Italian) though, Kathryn, you have helped a lot!

[joavka]

I went to Meatless Monday at Dell'anima when I was on vacation in NYC in December and it was very good. However, I do think that there are also excellent vegetarian options at Scarpetta (been in NYC and also Toronto).