Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Chicago Area >
May 6, 2012 11:24 PM

GT Fish & Oyster and Nellcôte, stylish and sceney but both a bit hit and miss.

Full review in the blog, text as below:

GT Fish and Oyster:

With the donut showdown barely over the first proper meal on my Chicago agenda was at GT Fish & Oyster, a restaurant that had gotten rave reviews since the day it opened and given the diverse seafood-centric menu focused on ‘small plates/big taste’ it seemed a great choice after all the sugar and starch at breakfast, and all the more so in the setting of uncharacteristically beautiful weather. Admittedly having never visited any of the other BOKA restaurant group locations, an added bonus of the 1:00pm reservation was the chance to see what Giuseppe Tentori’s cuisine was all about.

Located on North Wells and often full throughout lunch according to my friend, particularly on a Friday, I arrived to GTF&O minutes prior to my confirmed reservation and with both the patio and the dining room busy but not jammed packed I was greeted by the hostess and quickly led to a table on the cusp on the patio but out of the sun – a prime spot save for the fact that waiters seemed incapable of avoiding my chair as they carried plates in and out the door and after sitting for a few moments one of these servers approached – a man named Kevin who quite liked the phrases ‘my friend’ and ‘bro’ when addressing both my table and the one next to me. With the menu already present on the table before Kevin arrived he asked if I would like a cocktail and on declining he persisted in suggesting I take a look at the list to see if anything changed my mind…which it did not.

Left to my decisions for the better part of fifteen minutes despite knowing what I wanted within a couple I spent some time perusing the scene – a vivacious bar crowd even at lunch indulging in a large platter of iced oysters, dark wood floors, ivory wood walls plus obvious nautical influences largely dominating my view then and later replaced by a large party of eight at the banquet next to me. A pleasant space overall and bathed in natural light I have to admit I was surprised that the restaurant was rather quiet, but seeing it at only half-capacity I imagine the nighttime scene is quite different.

When Kevin finally returned I inquired about a couple of items failing to list the specific fish utilized and with the explanation that this changes depending on what is fresh I made my choices – 3 savories and a sweet – while sticking with water as my beverage of choice, and with no bread service it would be perhaps fifteen to twenty minutes before the Clam Chowder with Neuske’s Bacon and House Made Oyster Crackers arrived in a flip-top jar. Certainly not GT’s most adventurous option but amongst the most celebrated I quickly took a bite and despite it being a bit too hot I was impressed, the creamy potage wowing with a smooth and buttery body, tender clams balanced by ample potatoes, and a smoky note that perfumed the palate. Generally not one to use crackers in soup but intrigued by the “house made” connotation I’ll additionally note that while I’d have simply preferred some table bread to go with the soup the rosemary tinged brioche nuggets were quite good, though really unnecessary as the soup was quite textural even without.

At this point with an empty water glass as back-waiters seemed clueless and Kevin had disappeared my empty bowl was collected after perhaps ten minutes and with my water then refilled I would wait…and wait…and wait for nearly thirty minutes before I flagged down a young lady and asked what was going on – an answer I never received, but to my best guess was either a computer or service glitch that led to my subsequent dishes never being prepared; a situation that was rectified with only a “sorry about that” after a nearly forty-five minute gap between appetizer and my 2-dish main course that the kitchen felt compelled to serve simultaneously despite both dishes being warm.

Beginning first with the Rock Fish Tacos with Garlic Marinade, Chipotle Aioli, and Chicharron I was served two of Tentori’s house made hot sauces – smolder and (wait for it…) burn – which Kevin suggested I add a ‘dash’ of if the tacos weren’t spicy enough. Generally not a fan of too much heat and wanting to taste the tacos at face value first I picked up one of the doubled soft corn tortillas and, well, generally not being a fan of bland-but-briny I ended up with more than a dash of sauce on each subsequent bite which helped to smooth out the salinity of the chicharron but did little to help the under-portioned dry fish.

Faring better than the tacos, another dish that has become sort of a GTF&O signature was the “GT Lobster Mac and Cheese with English Peas,” a shallow but indulgent bowl of tender orechiette loaded with buttery nuggets of lobster and a twist of lime bathed in breadcrumbs and a blend of well balanced cheeses. An excellent dish already I’m rather uncertain as to what inspired Tentori and team to add the tender early season peas to the dish, but adding a splash of color and a touch of sweet it was a lovely choice.

At this point quite full and a tad miffed at the lackluster service but committed to trying dessert as the menu contained one of my very favorite options I was offered coffee, which I declined, and nearly 115 minutes after walking through the doors the “Date Cake with Rum Toffee Sauce, Pecans, and Crème Fraiche” arrived to slightly mixed feelings. Beginning first with the good – if you like sticky toffee pudding or sweet desserts in general there is no denying that this steamed round was exemplary; a lovely sponge rife with fibrous dates and saturated with boozy toffee sauce as the crunchy pecans served as both a textural foil and a slightly bitter balance. Moving on to the not so good – just look at the quenelle of Crème Fraiche…far too sour, far too dense, and far too much even in the setting of such a sweet dessert.

With the bar area slowing down but the tables now mostly occupied it would not be long before Kevin would return, while I was till eating my dessert, and drop of the check with a “whenever you’re ready” and modeling his substandard approach to service I paid the tab with a substandard tip before standing up and making my way outside nearly $60 lighter in my wallet for food that ranged from decent to very good and service that was far less so. Call me a dissenter but I guess I just don’t get the hype, not in a city with so many other similar restaurants serving equal or better food with much better service. Having always wanted to check out Tentori’s cuisine at Boka I must say that my experience at GT Fish & Oyster did not exactly move it up on my list, though I anticipate service gaffs would be attenuated in a finer dining establishment.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Nellcôte:

    Having mentioned that the planning for this trip to Chicago was a bit last minute, it was also a trip during which I didn’t particularly want to ‘break the bank’ as I was just returning from an over-the-top visit to New York and would be leaving for a ten day family trip to Canada two weeks later…besides, Next El Bulli was going to cost enough. Thankfully fortunate to be in a position where ‘break the bank’ is relative and also visiting a city where the mid-range dining scene is quite robust there were obviously many contenders, but for the first night of my visit the decision was made to visit Nellcôte with my friend Rich (

    A relative newcomer in the bourgeoning Fulton Market, and opening to somewhat mixed reviews only weeks before my arrival, Nellcôte is the creation of Jared Van Camp – a young chef but a veteran of Chicago’s food scene as well as one of its strongest proponents of the Locavore/Farm to Table movement, a concept quite prominent on the small plates menu. Reportedly a multi-million dollar renovation of the space previously housing Marche and at least according to early reports money well spent plus a menu featuring a number of enticing dishes a reservation was made for 5:15pm – strikingly one of only two open slots on their stuffed reservations list (the other at 11:00pm.


    Still not particularly hungry given my breakfast and lunch but having spent the better part of 2 hours walking the streets of Chicago my arrival at Nellcôte would precede their opening the doors and waiting for my friend I saw multiple folks walking in and out the back with bags of vegetables, meats, and an enormous block of cheese. With workers arriving and the first patrons walking through the doors just after 5:00 it would not be long before my friend arrived and with greetings exchanged we entered through the revolving front door to a space just as brilliant as I’d expected, a literal wall of lavender greeting us.

    Progressing further into the space and subsequently greeted by a pair of hostesses at an iron gate it would be mere seconds before we were escorted to a high top in the middle of the room and asking if perhaps a seat by the window could be accommodated instead we were promptly moved to the front of the room, at this point bathed in light and showing off the dramatic ceilings, ornate candelabras, and copious smattering of chandeliers. Obviously a space meant to impress the best comparison I could come up with was a modernized and stylized Versailles’ Hall of Mirrors – not a bad place to be compared to, and complete with mirrors for a crowd that would later consist of pretty people trying very hard to look pretty while dining.

    Noting the atmosphere, one clearly focused on style and ‘scene’ (open until 2am, with a DJ coming on later in the evening,) I will say that even before sitting down I had wondered just how much substance would be delivered by the front of the house but after warm welcome we were handed off to a pleasant young woman named Ruth who would initially put my mind at ease despite utilizing much of the verbiage I’ve come to expect from a ‘hip’ spot – clever and witty, everything ‘sooo good’ or ‘my favorite,’ and plenty of adjectives delivered with a big smile. Having heard some initial reviews claim that service was not up to snuff I think it bears mention here that both Rich and I found Ruth to be a very good server throughout the evening, making recommendations both on the Nellcôte menu and other local favorites all while serving what seemed to be at least fifteen tables.

    With the menu having undergone some changes from the online opening-week version we were left to our decisions for a few moments before Ruth would return with what she described as the night’s amuse – a selection of crisp crudités with garlic aioli; all organic, all fresh and snappy, and an interesting choice I’d have not expected but clearly suggesting Van Camp’s vision for the menu. With decisions on food not yet made we instead opted to order a cocktail each and with this order delivered to the bar Ruth would head to another table as the room went from nearly empty to nearly full within forty-five minutes of opening.

    With the suggestion of 2-3 sharable plates per person and orders placed it would not be long before our cocktails would arrive, and with Ruth attending to other tables it was here that service issues began. Having myself ordered a lovely and aromatic cocktail named “Rum – Bacardi 8, Fresh Pineapple, Lime, Apricot Liqueur” while my dining partner opted for another cocktail focused on house-made preserves the two cocktails were delivered without a word and literally placed at the center of the table as though we were to guess which was which – something we did successfully, but seemingly an odd choice that would unfortunately recur throughout the night as not one dish was presented with a single detail by the back waiters while Ruth was busily working at other tables.

    Sipping our beverages and catching up it would not be long before plates started to arrive from the kitchen and having been told that items would be “brought in waves like a tapas restaurant’ we weren’t surprised when the first pair was delivered, both dishes featuring the much discussed house ground flour…but we were caught a bit off guard when the second pair arrived thirty seconds later literally filling our table with food.

    For the first of these items, the $3 bread basket (or plate, as it were,) we were presented with a baguette, a pull-apart brioche, and a focaccia along with lightly salted whipped cultured butter and on taking half of each warm sample…yep, it was bread, good bread even – but certainly not as interesting as that at Girl and the Goat (who also charges) or many other places who serve their bread for free. Perhaps I was expecting ‘too much’ given the big to-do about their flour, but if nothing else I guess the $3 charge prevented me from ‘filling up’ on bread.

    Moving next to the second starch while Rich worked on another dish for fear of plates suffering as they cooled, “Radiatore - Duck Leg, Hen of Woods, Romano Beans, Cracklings” would immediately lend credence to the kitchen from my standpoint with the house made pasta springy, the light ‘sauce’ of pan jus from the mushrooms and duck savory and aromatic, and the admixture of savory confit and crispy skin adding a well orchestrated textural variety to the plate.

    While I worked on my part of the pasta my dining companion began to portion out the “Lamb - Grilled Loin, Braised Neck, Gnocchi, Olive Marmalade, Manchego, Sofritto,” and while the loin itself was nicely prepared to a rosy medium-rare, the biggest surprise was the generous portion for a mere $12, particularly when accounting for the accoutrements. Assuredly a dish I would not have ordered on my own, this was perhaps the course of the evening in terms of showing off Van Camp’s skills as it took a number of intense ingredients including briny olives, rich cheese, and garlicky tomatoes and balanced them seamlessly with the supple meat and pillowy gnocchi to form something rustic in flavor but visually striking on the plate.

    Having mentioned the ‘tapas’ concept and still working on our warm dishes while the fourth chilled plate sat awaiting our attention it was no more than fifteen minutes after the first four plates arrived that the next three appeared tableside – and to my ire, the servers actually thought they could ‘make room’ on the table…something that most certainly wasn’t going to happen, particularly as all three plates were hot, one was the most skill dependent of the evening, and one was a whole pizza.

    With servers dismissed and ostensibly returning the food to the kitchen for the team, dogs, or garbage disposal as I made it clear I did not want the food simply kept warm or reheated it was finally here that Ruth would return and having heard what happened an apology was uttered, stating that the kitchen was still working on timing, and letting bygones be bygones we fished the warm selections and moved on to the $9 “Foie Gras Torchon - Brioche, Marasca Cherries, Pickled Pistachios.” Featuring another excellent portion for the price, particularly in the setting of a restaurant that charges for bread, this dish presented an approximately 2-2.5oz round of creamy liver rolled in lightly pickled nuts along with four hemisected candied cherries and rich buttery brioche. Obviously as a fan of foie gras this was a dish I was happy to see on the menu and having heard others say in the past that they’ve never tried duck or goose liver because of the price and the fact that they ‘weren’t sure if they would like it,’ this also doubles as a great way to try it without breaking the bank…sort of like “gateway foie,” if you will.

    With our first round now finished and Ruth personally attending to our table at this point, a single dish arrived next and although conceptually a good idea, the $9 “Alaskan Halibut - Soft Scrambled Eggs, Piperade, Sturgeon Caviar” fell a little flat for the both of us, yet in different ways. Beginning first with the fish, roasted before a pan sear to finish, I personally felt it was nicely prepared in the context of the dish well flavored while Rich felt it overcooked and a bit dry. Moving next to the sauces, pleural, generally not a fan of intense red pepper I actually found the piperade to be the better of the who if only because ‘soft scrambled eggs’ did not seem to me like it would be a buttery custard sauce that although tasty in the way that butter, eggs, and cream generally mostly served to mute the subpar roe.

    Having sent the previous attempts at our next two savories back, there would be a welcomed delay as we worked on the Halibut but with the kitchen clearly working at a very rapid pace and the restaurant necessarily wanting to turn tables given their fully booked reservations our last two savories would arrive just after 6:15 – an hour after we’d sat down. Beginning first with an $8 plate of “Saffron Risotto - Fava Beans, Bone Marrow, Pecorino, Gold Leaf,” suffice it to say that sending this plate back was probably the best idea of the night because what returned was on par with the best risotto I have ever had. Thick and rich, salty and aromatic, and toothsome yet smooth with the fava beans and marrow presenting a bold textural point/counterpoint…it was so good I didn’t even mind the superfluous gold leaf.

    With the aforementioned pizza our final savory and, perhaps, ‘main course’ it was decided early on that the best way to see how well the oven treated the house-milled flour with the most simplistic pie on the menu – the “Buffalo Mozzarella Pizza - Tomato Sauce, Basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil.” A Margherita by any other name and utilizing house made sauce from local tomatoes, fresh basil, and puddles of American Buffalo Mozz at the bargain price of $10 this dish was yet another example of the fine quality of ingredients on display at Nellcôte while the blistered and bubbly edges blistered and medium-wet center walked the fine line between crunch and chew, smoke and sweet.

    Sated at this point with Rich leaving a single slice of pizza and myself declining to finish it as it had cooled and I was looking forward to the sweets, Ruth would again stop by with the nightly menu and after chatting with us a bit about a few local spots she really enjoyed two selections were made, although all six sounded quite good, and after a short time the duo would arrive. Beginning first with a $4 trio of house made ice creams, seemingly an uncharacteristic order for myself until you looked at the flavors – Salted Caramel, Stracciatella, and La Colombe – what arrived in that small metal bowl can only be described as slightly melted perfection at a price substantially smaller than the norm. Beginning first with creamy vanilla flecked with dark chocolate and moving next to the brine meets butter sweetness of the caramel and then finally to my favorite blend in perhaps its ideal form each quenelle was better than the last, my only complaint being that I wish they would been served colder or brought from the kitchn more quickly.

    For our final taste of the evening, the Baba Au Rhum with Bachelor’s Jam and Crème Chantilly arrived alongside the trio of ice creams and noting right away that this was much more in the style of the Italian Bakery Baba than the thick French version popularized by Ducasse I was excited. Again featuring the house blend flour, this time in a sort of mushroom shaped popover with a buttery golden shell overlying an open spongy crumb my half of the baba went very quickly, each warm bite as good as the last with the dense cream and thick jam of dehydrated raisins and stone fruits proving a fine balance to the syrupy liquid filling the sponge. Probably a little more impressed by this dish than my friend I will note that while there is clearly rum present, this is a very sweet dessert and for those expecting a big wallop of booze you should probably look elsewhere.

    My friend now full and myself nearing the same as we worked slowly on dessert and discussed our other dining plans for the weekend Ruth would return to check on us just after 7:00pm and stating that she could bring the check whenever she liked it would not be long before she returned, again apologizing for the timing issues of early on, and thanking us for coming in – a nice gesture and well deserving of a good tip considering how many tables she was covering and how inefficient the ancillary staff, particularly as the total bill came out to less than $60 per person for nine plates and two drinks, a veritable bargain and hopefully enough when combined with the bar scene to allow time for kinks to be worked out since much of the cuisine already matches the restaurant’s seemingly lofty ambitions.

    1. I has a similar impression of GT Fish and Oyster (liked but did not love) but we didn't get the lobster roll (I noticed neither did you). You also didn't get any oysters? I also noticed that their dinner menu is a lot more interesting than their lunch menu (crudo, ceviche, oyster po boy sandwiches, etc).

      1 Reply
      1. re: kathryn

        Cold lobster rolls do nothing for me, so no. Oysters, similarly, are something I'll eat but rarely/never order in a raw state.

        I do agree that the dinner menu looks better, but I've no intention to find out.

      2. Great report. We're visiting this month and had this place high on our list. I'm concerned now. The main reason this was high on our list was due to the comparisons made to Neptune's Oyster in Boston. That it was modeled after them. We loved NO in our visit last year and my wife fell in love with the lobster roll with butter, not mayo. We cannot get lobster rolls like that here in Los Angeles.

        I'm concerned now as I respect yours and Kathryn's opinion very much. But we may still visit as my wife would be devastated if I changed my mind after all the anticipation ever since I mentioned lobster rolls and the NO comparison. I just hope that the rolls are good and since neither you or Kathryn had the roll, it will be the saving grace.

        7 Replies
        1. re: Jase

          The GT Fish rolls are the mayo based kind:

          I've had the Neptune Oyster butter based lobster roll and I have to say that is a VERY tough roll to live up to.

          1. re: kathryn

            Thanks! We'll have to discuss. The roll was the main draw and we're leery about mayo based ones. It's too easy to have a heavy hand and have the mayo overwhelm the lobster. That picture and description seems like it's heavy on herbs and seasonings along with the amount of celery which would easily overwhelm the lobster.

            We might cut this back to splitting the roll and a couple of other dishes for a quick snack either at end of lunch hour or beginning of dinner.

            Yeah, NO's roll is a pretty high bar and I accepted that in comparing it to anything else. Was hoping for something good, not necessarily great when compared to NO. Thanks again.

            1. re: Jase

              Just a warning- I like GT and we actually had a really nice dinner there the other night- but they have downsized the lobster roll. It is good but I wouldn't necessarily go there just for that- it's not a full sized lobster roll any more, although it used to be when it first opened.

              1. re: ms. mika

                Thanks! This is rapidly falling down the list. Appreciate the feedback. I did have a pretty big list per my other post soliciting critiques. Glad I researched a lot of options.

            2. re: kathryn

              Agreed - and in general I felt Neptune superior to GTF&O in every single manner - though for my dollar, I'd go to Island Creek Oyster Bar in Boston over either of them.

              The lobster roll at NO, however, is unreal.


              1. re: uhockey

                We did both on our trip. I wouldn't turn down either. ICOB was the best meal of the visit and we had a fantastic time. My trip report is nowhere near as nice as yours but I hope I was able to convey how much we enjoyed it.

                I do think it is a bit of an apples and oranges comparison. ICOB a more refined experience while NO a more casual setting. I'd kill to have something close to either one here in LA.

                1. re: Jase

                  Boston would kill to have something similar to Urasawa, Animal, or ink, I'd imagine. :-)

                  Thanks for the compliment though. ICOB was awesome and I only wish I'd have been able to commit to it more fully.

                  GT F&O is just not worth the hype IMO - on that 3 day trip I had better meals at Nellcote, 2 Sparrows, Bar Toma, Yusho, EL Ideas, Publican, and Next. The only worse meal I had was Sprout.


          2. This is very useful. I have GT booked for a special occasion in June and am now considering changing the res.

            My only question is: if the food and service are so uninteresting or even inept, why is has it been so hard to get in there, even before the Chicago Mag "best new restaurants" article?

            5 Replies
              1. re: chicgail

                Chicgail - if you have it booked for a special occasion, I would recommend someplace else. I went a couple of months ago and found it to be just ok. But for the prices - just ok doesn't cut it. I didn't like the service or the ambiance.

                1. re: lbs

                  My other choice is Ada St. It's relatively new and off the Clybourn Corridor. Anyone been there yet? Would you choose it over GT Oyster? I have reservations both places and want to cancel one.

                  1. re: chicgail

                    Our server at Nellcote RAVED Ada Street, and I've heard very positive things, but I haven't been.

                    For the same price-point I'd suggest Yusho, Nellcote, Publican, or Avec personally.


                    1. re: chicgail

                      Having chosen Ada St, I thought I would report back. It's in a hard-to-find industrial street that you can't find without a GPS. No name, only the address on the door. LPs lining the walls. Small plates. Creative drinks named after songs.

                      It hit every right note it could think of and should be amazing. It wasn't.

                      The crowd is very young. We felt like everyone else's parents. Or maybe grandparents. i exaggerate, of course. But not much.

                      The food is small plates, which I normally love. We really wanted to like the food. Polenta fries in "chipotle" ketchup that tasted like Heinz instead of chipotle. Unmemorable softshell crab with an avocado creme sauce. Really nice crispy lamb ribs in a very sweet mango habenaro sauce with no hint of habenaro. We did like the asparagus spears scented with truffle creme and very soft-boiled eggs.

                      It's a better place for a drink (or three) and a snack than dinner. More in the mode of Aviary or even Sable. It may have legs, if mostly as a hip bar. The mixologist (who called himself the Spiritual Advisor) left after only 6 weeks. I don't know if he's been replaced. The chef has chops, having worked for both Thomas Keller and Tom Coliccio, but we were not impressed.

                      We love Publican and maybe should have tried Nellicote or Yosho instead. Maybe other people have had different experiences.


                2. I just ate at Nellcote. Frankly, I was offended by the experience. We were a party of 6. The reception was very spotty and we were seated 30 minutes after our reservation time with barely an apology. Even though we were 6 people we were only given three menus for our table. Service was spotty. Our waitress was very nice but seriously, she was totally overwhelmed. The most frequent thing uttered from her mouth was "I'm sorry". Over and over again all night. From the 30 minutes it took to make our "hand crafted cocktails" (which were only just okay, I've had better elsewhere) to the genreally slow service (at times we only had 3 plates on the table for 6 people), this was just not a well oiled machine. I get that it's new. But I've been to plenty of new restaurants but seriously, these kinks that they have seem endemic. Fix them!! Overall the food was tasty, I'll give them that. we split a number of pizzas (overall good, i liked the one with the egg on it and the one with burrata the best), as well as the hamachi, the steak, the salmon, the potatoes, the skatewing and the sweetbreads. All tasty, but seriously, for 6 people, one must order a ton of food, especially if people are hungry. That said, we only spent $60 a person. The restaurant was beautiful, but it was too loud, and there were too many people with seriously questionable fashion sense. Despite the pretty good food, I wont return. The experience was exhausting and there are tons of great restaurants in Chicago so why bother?