Log In / Sign Up
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
treestonerivershrub Apr 8, 2012 04:25 PM

Best homemade stock in a Japanese restaurant?

I'm looking for Japanese restaurants that take the trouble to make delicious, homemade stock for their soups. I know there must be places in Manhattan that do this, but I have had no luck finding them. Everyone seems to take short cuts, thinking that no one notices the difference, but I make broth and stock all the time and make dashi from scratch regularly, so I am pretty picky about what constitutes a good soup.

Samurai Mama, in Williamsburg, is the only restaurant so far I've been able to find that does a proper, nutrient-dense, complex tasting, soul-warming homemade stock...but with all the great Japanese restaurants (and plenty of Japanese people), especially in Midtown area, there have to be places I've overlooked.

So please, enlighten me!

  1. r
    Ricky Apr 8, 2012 05:02 PM

    Kyo Ya
    15 East - they make excellent nimono
    Kajitsu - vegan dashi
    Uminoie - ago dashi
    Sushi You
    Cotan - too bad its closed
    Kanoyama
    Momokawa

    4 Replies
    1. re: Ricky
      treestonerivershrub Apr 9, 2012 08:32 AM

      Hi,

      This is great, thanks for all the suggestions. I love nimono, too!

      1. re: Ricky
        f
        foodwhisperer Apr 10, 2012 09:13 AM

        Ricky
        I like your list, i have not been to Uminole or momokawa. I like the broth at Brushstroke, and also the miso broth at Misoya as well.

        1. re: foodwhisperer
          treestonerivershrub Apr 11, 2012 12:43 PM

          Two more nice suggestions, thanks foodwhisperer. What kind of broth was it at Brushstroke?

        2. re: Ricky
          f
          foodwhisperer Jun 1, 2012 08:50 PM

          I went to Umino-ie the other night. I had said in another post that I had not been there. In fact I had been there a few times, but never saw a sign or a name. So I had been asking around about Kyushu izakaya, a Japanese friend of mine recommended this place. I walked in and laughed, because I knew the place. In the past, the stew stuck out in my mind. It was so "homestyle" and good. But this time, the Goto Islands style Udon was in one of the best broths I have ever had. It was totally amazing. That was the best dish of the evening.

        3. s
          Simon Apr 8, 2012 05:02 PM

          The broth w/ the clams at Aburiya Kinnosuke was fragrant and not too salty and yummy last week.

          Share with your friendsX