Midtown grocery stores?
Where do y'all buy your daily comestibles in Manhattan? I'm here for awhile at 5th and 59th and will go broke if I have to buy everything from room service. I want a source of cereals, fresh produce items, milk and also some CRUSHED ICE so I don't have to pay room service to bring it.
As I recall last time this happened, I was near Penn Station and bought some ice from a Korean market under the table because the cashier went back and filled a plastic grocery bag from their ice machine. But that can't be the norm.
New Yorkers look great but that can't be just because you never eat at home and never put ice in your drinks. Let me in on your secrets please.
P.S. Yes I know there's a Whole Foods in Columbus Circle but am looking for closer/alternate sources.
RCC no ice machines, you have to call room service/butler. (This is the Plaza.)
But I've found Klein and it's great. Ice is $2.99 for 5 lbs. Also a great selection of IPAs and Belgian style ales. Also, WellGreen is on the west side of 6th between 57th and 58th so just a block from my hotel. They seem in general a wee bit cheaper than Klein's and their 5 lbs of ice is $2.50.
I do put ice in my drinks... But it's cubed. Many NYers live in apartments where the fridges are older and smaller. Not the stainless steel kind with the built in ice dispenser you see a lot elsewhere.
Keep in mind you're also in an extremely touristy part of town--by Central Park, the Apple Store, etc. Where's your office? Are you commuting to somewhere else in Manhattan? It might be easier to pick something up on the way back to 5th and 59th.
There are Food Emporium supermarkets on Third Avenue in the mid-60s and on First between 59th and 60th. There's a smaller deli-grocery store on 59th between Madison and Park (is it called Delmonicos?). I don't know that this is something that would interest you, but there's a Japanese grocery (Katagiri) on 59th between Second and Third - where there's also a good pastry shop, Financier.