HOME > Chowhound > Northern New England >

REVIEW: Prohibition PIg - Waterbury, VT

MightyFrog Apr 4, 2012 02:24 PM

Vermonters: go eat there.

OK, that's the most important part of the review. Prohibition Pig recently opened in the space The Alchemist used to occupy before Tropical Storm Irene. They've hit the ground running; my wife and I ate there the second week they were open and it's STILL difficult to get a table. They specialize in smoked meats, and living just down the street I can testify that I am about 10% hungrier all the time if the wind from that smoker is blowing right.

We started with an appetizer of fried pimiento cheese with red pepper jelly. The crumb coating was a bit messy and they could have done with maybe another 30 seconds in the fryer; still, we scarfed them down quickly. The combination of rich cheese, crunchy breading, and the sweet jelly was a welcome, unexpected contrast. For a main course, I got the beef brisket sandwich with fried onions. Just . . . fantastic. I grew up in north Louisiana and the only brisket I ever had that beat this one came from an old Texan at a family reunion. My wife got the Carolina-style pulled pork with a vinegary sauce and a great, slow-building heat. She's diabetic and can't eat starchy side orders. She was pleasantly surprised to find a real choice of vegetable options. Blackened green beans and roasted brussel sprouts, both simple but well-prepared.

I'm an amateur mixologist with a bit of bartending experience. To some extent I'm GLAD they're charging prices appropriate to high-end craft cocktails, because otherwise I could be in real danger living so close. :) My wife had a sidecar (Armagnac, lemon, and Cointreau) that was the best she'd ever tasted. I had a complex cocktail called a Pinfall Marks (rye, Chartreuse, Cynar, grapefruit, lemon, and Angostura) that showed great attention to detail and subtlety. The restaurant carries a huge variety of beer as well.

Prohibition Pig seems well thought out start to finish. Good design of the physical space and menus, house-made pickles, enticing meat smoking outside, a good downtown location--they've got everything going for them. Highly recommended.


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Morganna RE: MightyFrog Apr 5, 2012 08:15 AM

    God I wanna go. Wanna go wanna go. I wish they served lunch! I'm going to be working in Waterbury again probably sometime early next month!

    1 Reply
    1. re: Morganna
      bm_vt RE: Morganna Apr 5, 2012 12:50 PM

      I wanna go too! Thanks for the review. Gotta find an excuse to go to Waterbury now!

    2. t
      tkln RE: MightyFrog Apr 6, 2012 07:50 AM

      So glad to hear this...do they have more tables than the Alchemist did? I remember reading the pool table is gone so I'm hoping that means more seating. I will miss the Alchemist's BLT though - my favorite!

      4 Replies
      1. re: tkln
        MightyFrog RE: tkln Apr 7, 2012 08:40 AM

        No more tables, sadly. And given how popular the place is, that's a problem! I once went in at 5:30 on a Tuesday and there was already a 45-minute wait for a two-top.

        1. re: MightyFrog
          Morganna RE: MightyFrog Apr 7, 2012 02:48 PM

          Can you call it in and get it to go?

          1. re: MightyFrog
            jjadamsfb RE: MightyFrog Apr 7, 2012 07:33 PM

            There are 3 extra tables wherre the pool table was, but not much more than that. It was always the problem with The Alchemist, but I guess being too popluar is a good problem to have.

            1. re: MightyFrog
              tkln RE: MightyFrog Apr 9, 2012 01:11 PM

              Ugh, oh well....we always used to go to the Alchemist as soon as they opened for the day to avoid the wait...guess we can continue in that tradition!

          Show Hidden Posts