Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Apr 4, 2012 05:41 AM

fresh manicotti--make day before or day of?

I want to make some homemade manicotti for Easter. I've made it several times, but always cooked it immediately after making the pasta and filling them. Do you think it's ok to prepare the manicotti the night before and keep it in the fridge? (Prepare as in fill them, sauce them, put them in the pan they're going to be cooked in the next day)

If not, can I make the pasta dough the day before, wrap it, keep it in the fridge overnight and then roll and fill the next morning? (again, I've made fresh pasta hundreds of times, but never stored it...)


  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I make homemade manicotti as well. I don't see why you couldn't make it the day before. You could also make them now and freeze the manicotti individually and then defrost and sauce on Easter morning.

    1. I have done manicotti both ways, and don't see an appreciable difference. You're making the one with the pasta and not with the crespele, right? I find that when I make them (either way) and bake the next day, I need a tad more sauce. But there should be no difference. They should be fine either way.

      1. I agree with Jans and roxlet. Manicotti isn't very different from lasagna which is fine made a day I wouldn't worry at all. (You don't want to keep pasta dough for very long, even overnight when raw it can turn grey because of the eggs.)

        1. I've often made and stuffed cannelloni (which I think is the same as manicotti made with pasta) a day, even two, before serving.
          And I hope the rolled out pasta I dried slightly and refrigerated will last a few days as I'm planning on making cannelloni tomorrow to serve Saturday night.

          1. So how was your trip to Paris?