HOME > Chowhound > Austin >

Discussion

Clay Pit

Evening all,

Know the place has been discussed over the years in general Indian food threads, but few recent posts, so hoping it is ok to give Clay Pit its own new thread here.

I know very little of Indian food aside from the occasional inexpensive buffets I have gone to against my will where I have tended to find overcooked meat and more spice than I can handle. I have only been to Clay Pit once before- a few years ago- where I had naked grilled meat out of fear of spicy sauces from my limited other experiences with Indian food.

Big miss on my part. Tonight's dinner was wonderful. Two of us going "family style". Here goes,

Lamb Roganjosh- mild option requested. This was very good. Nicely robust, properly cooked lamb, and mild, but noticeable heat on the seasoning. Suffered a bit alongside the other two dishes which were surprisingly elegant, but only for lack of the common thread those other two shared shared.

Kabuli Chicken- mild option requested. Marvelous. Lovely texture- nuts and fruits well-pureed, and with an unexpected elegance. The chicken was cooked PERFECTLY. Nice small chunks, very light browning and brilliantly tender. I find it very rare in any restaurant to have chicken exactly right when it comes to cooking. That made the dish for me.

Vegetable Ayam- mild option requested. I could eat this every day. A mix of fresh very thinly sliced carrots and larger chunks of zucchini, squash, broccoli and cauliflower- each of them cut in a way that suggests that if they were all cooked together, someone took the time to apply varying shapes and sizes to each vegetable to ensure uniform results. As with the chicken, the saucing here was very elegant- garlic and curry making their presence, but not the least bit overpowering or intrusive.

Basmati rice also very well prepared. The naan was quite nice- substantial but not heavy. Not sure why there was butter on it, but it did not detract from overall performance.

As for the inevitable question of "authenticity", I have absolutely no idea guys. As I said before, my experience with Indian food is very limited- and only the lamb bore a strong resemblance to what little I have tried before. I will leave that argument to those who know the cuisine better, but I found tonight's dinner for it's own sake most enjoyable and a welcome departure from my usual fare.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. very consistent resturaunt in my opinion

    1. "I know very little of Indian food aside from the occasional inexpensive buffets"
      "As for the inevitable question of "authenticity", I have absolutely no idea guys. As I said before, my experience with Indian food is very limited"

      Thanks for your review but based on those comments, you might as well be reviewing your first steak after being a vegetarian all your life or your first big city meal as you come off the farm.

      If you are not familiar with Indian food than the Clay Pit may dazzle you. It even has a cool building that it sits in, complete with cellar dining. After that though if you have been to a truly Authentic Indian restaurant in a city like Singapore or even India itself, you will know that we are lacking in Austin. The Clay Pit is a nice, mild, "date night" Indian restaurant. Their newly opened "fast-casual" restaurants, "Tarka" seem far more authentic when it comes to flavors than the Clay Pit. And what are we really talking about when we talk Indian? Spice, flavor, texture, curries, naan, North or South India, all of it and as much of it as we can get. :)

      As a whole, most of the Indian restaurants in the United States serve Americanized versions of North Indian food, which is generally less spicy. South Indian restaurants also exist and are slowly becoming popular but are less preferred because the food is considered very spicy.

      I am anxiously awaiting the "eat with your hands on a banana leaf" type of Indian restaurant that I have experienced overseas and when it comes to Austin, I will be smiling through burning lips and watery eyes! :)

      3 Replies
      1. re: blueclaw666

        Agreed. I have a friend who loves Clay Pit, and I've eaten there with her quite a few times. I've been disappointed with the lack of flavor in every single dish of theirs that I've tried (oddly, I liked Tarka reasonably well he one time I ate there with her...and of course she wasn't a fan). The food at Clay Pit is just too bland for Indian food, in my opinion. I hate to be "that guy," but after spending ten years in the Bay Area in California I sure miss the quality and consistency of Indian food there. I've never been to India.

        1. re: blueclaw666

          Sorry blueclaw666, but this comment seems a little dickish.

          I didn't notice hounds getting as personal with you after your recent recommendations of P.F.Chang's, Hooters and Torchy's Tacos.

          1. re: Alan Sudo

            No dickishness meant and my replies to those other posts were in-line with what they were asking about. Whose throwing it around now, Alan?

            I would edit to remove seeming dickishness if I could. My apologies.

        2. I also hate to be that guy, and admittedly haven't been to India or eaten with my hands from banana leaves. But having worked as a scientist for so long and after living in the DC metro for 7 years, I have a lot of good Indian friends / colleagues that have cooked me meals and have been to first rate Indian restaurants. Anyone who has been to Woodlands, Udupi Palace, etc. in the Maryland DC suburbs knows where I'm coming from, especially for south Indian fare. Clay Pit may satisfy some, and I'm glad for that, because they have a client base and obviously remain open for a reason. I'm not a fan however and much prefer Chola's and the new south Indian leaning Asiana (my new favorite Indian place in town). Asiana is arguably the most authentic south Indian non vegetarian joint we have. Their heat on most of their dishes is awesome and the flavors deep and complex. Love that place. Austin's getting there, slowly but surely.

          1 Reply
          1. re: slowcoooked

            That's exciting. I need to try Asiana soon!

          2. I have an Indian friend who loves to go to Clay Pit with other Indians. I think that they like it because it is "Indian enough" but different. There's a lot of home cooking going on, and then many of the restaurants are similar to eating at home (according to him).

            We go to lunch all the time - I never get to eat Indian food because he is always tapped out on it.

            1 Reply
            1. re: rudeboy

              Indian but different as an attraction is spot on.

              My husband is Pakistani and I do a lot of socializing with Indian and Pakistanis. The Clay Pit is often a suggested by friends as a choice for nice meals out because it is upscale and fancy compared to other desi options. No, the food is not 'authentic.' Does one need credentials to say something like that? I don't know, but I have lived in India and Dubai (pretty much an Indian satellite city in the Arabian Peninsula), speak several Indian languages, have travelled extensively in South Asia, and I know Indo-Pak regional cooking very intimately---I cook it myself on a regular basis for my family.

              The owners of Clay Pit are Pakistani, I believe of Indian Gujarati origin (Ismaili community)...not that they serve food remotely close to what is served in their particular ethnic community. You will never find food like that in a restaurant. The food doesn't have to be authentic, though. It should just be enjoyable.

              For authentic North Indian (Punjabi) I would recommend the goat curry or egg curry at Teji's. Totally different atmosphere than Clay Pit, though. Much more 'authentic' than your average creamy faux Mughlai-Punjabi buffet fare. But for a nice meal in a more upscale atmosphere, Clay Pit for sure.

            2. I think the Clay Pit's great; as mentioned in this thread, it's pretty much the typical Indian food we see in the states, but just a step up. The sauces are tastier, the meat's cooked just a little bit better, not to mention the fact that the historic stone building is a nice contrast to the places where every surface is covered with saris.

              I know I've mentioned this before, but I'd HIGHLY recommend G'Raj Mahal if you're looking for something a little out of the ordinary. All of their standards are delicious, not to mention that they have a Goan section (the chef's from Goa). Try the rechard masala (I get it with fish). It's this very spicy chili sauce with a surprising vinegar element; it's like nothing I've ever had with respect to Indian food. Plus in general, it's nice to order your food spicy at an Indian restaurant and they actually give you really spicy food.

              All in all, I think it's probably my favorite Indian restaurant I've been to in the states. Give it a shot!