HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >

Substitute for Tilapia

m
MelDubya Mar 13, 2012 05:00 AM

I live in rural Australia, so the only wild fish I have access to (vs. the farmed basa and whiting at the store) is mostly reef fish since the great barrier reef is only 3 hours away. A lot of the American recipes I'd like to try have Tilapia in them though (which I've never seen here,) so I wondered if something like Barramundi, Grunter or Red Throat Emporer would be good substitutes as they're my fave fish and are easy to come by.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. carolinadawg RE: MelDubya Mar 13, 2012 05:19 AM

    Any mild, white fleshed fish could be substituted for tilapia. Its generally very thin, by the way. Personally, I'm not a huge fan, as it often tatses "muddy" to me.

    2 Replies
    1. re: carolinadawg
      m
      magiesmom RE: carolinadawg Mar 14, 2012 05:25 PM

      me too. I don't get the appeal.
      You can sub any white fish.

      1. re: magiesmom
        hill food RE: magiesmom Mar 14, 2012 05:35 PM

        I'd echo both carolina and magies. although I don't get a 'muddy' taste I just get a bland one.it's really just a cheap default fish (for me anyway). not bad but not something I'd seek out with anticipation. I'd rather have cod, but I understand Atlantic cod is on the over-fished list.

        odd you don't see it as much of what we get here in the US is farm-raised in Asia. maybe bless your luck you're surrounded by fertile seas and save your pity for us. </envy>

    2. s
      sueatmo RE: MelDubya Mar 13, 2012 07:26 AM

      I think Barramundi would work, if it is the same Barramundi I can get at my grocer. Tilapia is, as CD said, a thin white fleshed fish, so it is possible that cooking times might be different if the Barramundi is a bit thicker. Tilapia used to be a better quality, I think. I don't like it now. But it grills up firm without drying out, unless over cooked, and without falling apart. Just a few years ago I would have said it (tilapia) makes lovely sandwiches. At any rate, the Barramundi would make a fine sub in recipes.

      1. p
        Puffin3 RE: MelDubya Mar 13, 2012 08:14 AM

        I like basa a bit more. It's a firmer fleshed fish. Both are basically tasteless so you can add pretty well any flavors you want.

        1. Zeldog RE: MelDubya Mar 13, 2012 10:56 PM

          Meldubya,

          It's like you're asking if you could use sirloin instead of spam. Go with the reef fish. Tilapia is for people who don't like the taste of fish. Basa (also a fresh water fish) is pretty much the same as tilapia -- flaky, bland and dry, so use that if you really want to follow the recipe as closely as possible, but as Puffin3 says, "both are basically tasteless", and that's the bottom line. Tilapia is popular in the US because it is cheap and readily available even thousands of miles from an ocean, but any recipe will only be improved by using a mild, wild caught fish.

          1. g
            Gail RE: MelDubya Mar 14, 2012 11:33 AM

            I have eaten both tilapia and barramundi. I clearly prefer barramundi. They served it on an Air New Zealand flight from LA. Best airplane food ever. It was topped with a delicious tapenade.

            2 Replies
            1. re: Gail
              hill food RE: Gail Mar 14, 2012 05:44 PM

              ok between you, Zeldog and Sue I gotta track down some barramundi and basa.

              Sue - (sorry to go OT for the OP but) where do you find these? an Asian market on Olive in STL? cause I've never seen it at the usual suspects.

              1. re: hill food
                paulj RE: hill food Mar 17, 2012 10:01 AM

                Vietnamese basa fillets are common in the Asian markets I shop (e.g. HMart).

            Show Hidden Posts