Log In / Sign Up
HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >
h
hallettd Feb 23, 2012 10:46 AM

Where to eat in Niagara Falls/Buffalo area

My wife and I are going to Niagara Falls for a week. It’s been 23 years since we were last there. I’m sure most of places we ate are long gone. We’re planning daytrips to Rochester and Corning. Any suggestions on where to eat? TIA.

  1. r
    rochfood Mar 6, 2012 05:29 PM

    The locals enjoy Mighty Taco. A better taco bell. And local to Buffalo.

    1 Reply
    1. re: rochfood
      t
      tardigrade Mar 23, 2012 08:45 PM

      Mighty Taco is one small step above Taco Bell but they do have the local drink, loganberry soda. The big Buffalo specialty is beef on weck, predating wings. Schwabls' in West Seneca will give you the ur-beef on week experience, and Bar-Bill's in East Aurora is worth stopping in on if you're in the neighborhood. Try the birch beer - another local specialty, especially if it's draft.

      I've never been impressed with the food in Niagara Falls, although we stumbled upon The Falls and Firkin in some casino complex on the Canadian side which had decent beer and very good salads. I remember eating at a brewpub in Corning about 5 years ago that wasn't bad, but as others have said it's a good 3 hours from the Falls.

    2. l
      lsmutko Mar 1, 2012 12:08 PM

      Just downriver is Lewiston, and a restaurant I've never seen mentioned is definitely worth some more love. Carmelo's on Center St, upscale modern Italian, really excellent food, the dining room used to be the village jail in the 1800s, so it's old but not draped in Ye Olde-ness.
      http://www.carmelos-restaurant.com/

      The village itself is worth a stroll and they've really updated the waterfront. Stop in at DiCamillo's Bakery, try their "pizza bread," really focaccia or their sweet baked goods.
      http://www.dicamillobakery.com/

      If you're there when in the spring/summer/fall, get a cone of frozen custard at Hibbard's. It's quite delicious. No website.

      If you venture south to Buffalo, I highly recommend a hot dog stop at a Ted's. Local chain, flame-broiled dogs and burgers, and for a truly local flavor, a loganberry pop (not soda in WNY).
      http://www.tedsonline.com/

      6 Replies
      1. re: lsmutko
        h
        hallettd Mar 1, 2012 01:27 PM

        Carmelo's looks great. I love the history. I'm not sure my wife will go for Ted's but I may try sneaking it in. Thanks.

        1. re: hallettd
          c
          Cliocooks Mar 2, 2012 01:24 PM

          For frozen custard in Buffalo, try Anderson's. If you want a super-traditional taste of WNY you could always try Ulrichs, which is German food and one of the oldest places in town. Lots of good Italian places around, too, both traditional red-sauce places and some higher end contemporary ones. But of course locals don't only go to the traditional places, and the great thing about a city that's not too touristy is that you don't really risk ending up in the tourist places. The Anchor Bar might be the exception to that rule. If you ask people their favorite restaurant you'll get lots of different answers, of course, but Hutch's (on Delaware Ave) would rank pretty high on most lists, and it's been around long enough not to be thought of as trendy.

          Ted's is definitely worth a stop, and you must have loganberry with your hot dog.

          1. re: Cliocooks
            h
            hallettd Mar 2, 2012 02:47 PM

            I just flew in from Charleston, SC and I'm cold, so the frozen custard is out but the other 2 sound like what I'm looking for. Thanks.

            1. re: hallettd
              c
              Cliocooks Mar 6, 2012 05:04 PM

              Did you enjoy your trip?

              1. re: Cliocooks
                h
                hallettd Mar 22, 2012 01:41 PM

                I was reminded why we left upstate New York. It was cold.
                We had a great meal at Carmelo's in Lewiston. Found a really nice pastry shop in the same block as Carmelo's. Great fried fish at Mr B's in Niagara Falls. My wife will flighting up monthly. I may wait until it warms up.

                1. re: hallettd
                  c
                  Cliocooks Mar 23, 2012 03:05 PM

                  You picked the wrong week. We've had temperatures in the eighties this week!

      2. c
        Cliocooks Feb 25, 2012 04:51 PM

        What kind of food do you like?

        Corning will be a long day trip, but I'm sure you already know that. Have you considered including Buffalo in your itinerary? Good things to do here, too!

        3 Replies
        1. re: Cliocooks
          h
          hallettd Feb 27, 2012 06:38 AM

          Sure. We haven't been back to the area in years so we thought we'd do some day trips. And there doesn't seem to be many good restaurants in Niagara Falls. So where should we go in Buffalo?

          1. re: hallettd
            c
            Cliocooks Feb 29, 2012 05:23 PM

            Well if you're into architecture, there''s the Darwin Martin House by Frank Lloyd Wright, which is now almost completely restored. There are some pretty good architecxture tours, as well. and then there are the art museums, etc.

            AS to food, there are quite a few good places, Specific recommendations would depend on what kind of thing you like.

            1. re: Cliocooks
              h
              hallettd Mar 1, 2012 01:12 PM

              We're looking for a taste of Western NY. Where the locals go not necessarily the latest trend.

        Share with your friendsX