HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >

Discussion

Neptune's Net vs Malibu Seafood

  • j
  • johnpressman Jun 20, 2006 08:31 PM
  • 9

Passed by Malibu Seafood on my way to How's Market for some steaks (thank you Chowhounds). Have eaten at Neptune's Net in the past. How would you compare these two places? Does either one have something they do especially well? Prices??

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
Posting Guidelines | FAQs | Feedback
Cancel
  1. Good question...I've been wondering the same thing. We like driving up to Neptune's Net occasionally, but never been to Malibu Seafood. Which is better?

    1 Reply
    1. re: jp

      they are different.
      Neptune's net has the two sections - the fry-bar/burger grill and the steam area. The fry-bar is ok, you're better off with the burger than with the overbreaded fried sea creatures. Fries are ok. This is a branch off the market- nice beer selection, cookies etc. The steam area has local rock crab, dungeness brought in, sometimes local spiny lobster, shrimp and some shellfish, as well as chowder (which i like) and corn which is fine later in the summer. It's basically a market that makes up some food near the beach. It's the setting more than the food.

      malibu seafood is a restaurant. they have a wider selection (calamari for example) and I remmeber that they offer broiled fish which neptune's net does not.

    2. Malibu Seafood wins hands down. The fish and chips or the fish sandwich are great. So is the calimari.

      1. Neptune's Net offers fresh raw shell-on shrimp that one purchases by the pound (sold and prepared separately from the abysmal adjacent fried fish counter). You buy the raw shrimp, they'll steam it, and you take it to a table and peel and eat yourself silly and wash 'em down with cold bottled brewski. That is the pleasant part of the equation. If you choose to subject yourself to the fried fish and chowder counter, be prepared for apathy at best, and more likely, the stink-eye glare from various counterpeople with temperaments reflecting chronic constipation...

        1. I like the fish and chips at Malibu Seafood much better ...

          1. Malibu Seafood has the better meal. They're fish and chips would always win out over NN. MS's fries are probably the best in town and you are allowed to BYOB if you like (I saw a family with table cloth, jug wine, and lanterns at sunset last week).

            Neptune's Net has a harley biker atmosphere, which adds to the mix. They also sell beer, which MS does not. As others have noticed, their batter tends to overdo the breading.

            1. Malibu Seafood is a better choice for the fried stuff. For example, the fried fish plate. At MS, you get a nice long piece of battered fish. At NN, you get a flat thin filet, a little thinner than McDonald's fish fillet sandwich.

              However, the fresh steamed shrimp and steamed clams are good at NN. I had either the steam clams or mussels at MS and it was a waste of money since there were a lot of just empty shells in my bowl.

              Service is slow at both places on weekends.

              Bring $3 with you if you go to MS. If their parking lot is full and the street is full, you might be able to find a spot in the paid area. Put the $3 in an envelope and write your plate # on there.

              1. I really like the fish & chips at Malibu Seafood! I went to Neptune's Net once, and they were alright. Since MS is farther south, I'd rather just go there and not have to drive all the way up to NN.

                1. Yes, the consensus here is right. Malibu Seafood is leaps and bounds better than Neptune's Net. MS has a fish market on one side, and you order on the other side. All the seating is outdoors. Fish and chips are great--the clam strips are usually overdone but I'd gobble them anyway. Chowder is passable considering we're in L.A. Parking there can be a nightmare at lunchtime--be careful because you have to pay to park in the adjoining lot. Though it has never been so bad that I had to cross PCH! Eek! Neptune's Net is OK but only because there is nowhere else to go out there!