HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >


Bison meat in Toronto?

Does anyone know where I can buy fresh bison meat in Toronto? If not fresh, how about frozen? I know Bruno's has it but it is $11 a pound for frozen. I thought that was pretty expensive so I would like to find it somewhere else at a better price.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. White House in SLM and on Bayview

    1 Reply
    1. re: iMarilyn

      IIRC White House gets their bison from Second Wind Elk in the SL Farmers Market. Second Wind is less expensive, but White House has better cuts.

    2. http://www.mediumrare.to/gamemeatsele...

      Can't say it will be inexpensive, but they have great quality, which has not been my experience with the Bruno's near us, more often than not ...

      1 Reply
      1. re: CocoTO

        Totally agree. Picked up a Bison Rib Eye (among other things) last weekend. It cost close to $30/lb.

      2. I have purchased bison steak at the fresh meat counter at Whole Food several times. I remember they were around $27/lb and were very good.

        3 Replies
        1. re: 1moreround

          How did you cook yours? I bought them last week, marinated them, and grilled them medium rare and they were still super tough! I dont know what I did wrong!

          1. re: hungryabbey

            I do not marinate them at all. Just grilled them on the bbq to rare. I usually like my steak medium rare, but a butcher once told me bison has to be cooked rare because they have less fat content then beef (hence healthier). I did not find them tough at all cooked this way.

            1. re: 1moreround

              Hm. how strange. Well, I will try it again.

        2. Fiesta Farms usually has bison steaks, as does Healthy Butcher.

          1. bison tends to be more expensive than beef, i buy from cumbrae's or the booth at the liberty village farmer's market

            7 Replies
            1. re: ingloriouseater

              I have asked at Cumbrae's and all they have is frozen ground Bison meat, nothing fresh. Also I have bought Bison at Bruno's and was disappointed.
              I woudl love to buy a bison roast: where can I buy it

              1. re: Smachnoho

                I wouldn't bother spending the money on a bison roast. Not enough fat to make it worthwhile. (I'm speaking from experience!) I stick to bison rib-eye steaks (I find strip steak too tough) and cook no more than medium rare. It will never be quite as tender as a well-marbelled beef rib-eye, but the flavour is great and, from a health standpoint, it's worth it. I also love ground bison and use it often in chilis and for burgers.

                1. re: Tatai

                  I tend t cook bison steaks as I would an expensive beef steak. However, if you cook it as you would a cheap steak, slower and lower, you can get more tender results. This may work with roasts as well. Only a tasty experiment will tell.

                  I don't recommend buying frozen if you don't know how long it's been so. There just isn't enough fat IMO to keep it sub-zero without damaging the texture and taste.

                  Love the stuff. All the great taste of steak without the guilt. Love it.

                2. re: Smachnoho

                  i have ordered bison brisket through cumbrae's, they don't stock the items but can bring them in. steak has been done to death as has bison burgers. i have been doing braised bison brisket for about 8 years now...it was always way cheaper and fork tender...served with a saskatoon berry and cognac jus and some horseradish mashed potato and some really nice vegetables-truly my comfort meal to go to....

                  1. re: ingloriouseater

                    I have only made roast bison once in a slow cooker & it was great but I am willing to try bison brisket from Cumrae's. What size (pounds) should I order and about how much would it cost?

                    1. re: ingloriouseater

                      Port cherry sauce with home fries for me.

                      1. re: ingloriouseater

                        In my reply I was referring to my experience with dry-roasting bison, in my case, a standing rib roast of bison specially ordered at Cumbrae's. It was not successful. Have not made anything using braising/stewing cuts of bison.

                    1. re: TheDoughboy

                      I've eaten Ontario bison for many years but have never found a certified organic bison farmer in this province. The few that are fully grassfed with no finishing are equivalent to organic but are not 'certified'. The rest finish their animals with grass and grains which are not certified organic.
                      For cooking, I always follow the recipes and information on the Ontario based Bison Basics website ( www.bisonbasics.com )

                      1. re: BisonGuy

                        Thanks for the link. I think I am going to order some bison for a pot roast and use the online recipe.

                        1. re: BisonGuy

                          My mistake BisonGuy, Blanbrook Bison Farm are not certified Organic, from the description I had read though they are hormone/steroid free and a shorter description I read said they were grass fed, though digging in more said there are grains as well. They are still very tasty and as the local supplier has them that has always been my source when I want to cook up a bison roast.

                      2. As a big fan of Costco I have to plug it again here :)
                        They are also selling bison steaks online though they are pricey around 32$/lb for rib eye and strip loin.

                        1. Not sure the details on fresh vs. frozen, but Close to the Bone (Kingston Road near Victoria Park) has lots of interesting meats available to order.

                          1 Reply
                          1. re: blizzardgirl33

                            CTTB is good if you live in the area, but not worth a special trip.