Have done Branzino and Melograno for RW already, and were very pleased with both, but looking for someplace new. This is disappointing news because Salento's RW menu looks fantastic, but maybe it'll be Porcini? (I hear La Baia is quite loud).
A group of us did RW at Salento last RW and we weren't thrilled. The apps were fine. The mains were kinda boring. I haven't been to your other 2 places. The same group did have a great experience at Branzino.