Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > General Topics >
Jan 18, 2012 08:51 AM

Battle of the Balls Meatball Competitiion - Judging Criteria?

Three of my friends are arguing that they make the best meatball and want to have a Battle of the Balls competition! I have been anointed as one of the judges.

I'm trying to think of a good system for judging. Taste, uniqueness, healthiness, appearance, juiciness? Should one weigh more than the other?

How would you judge?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Great idea, but healthiness should be a concern only to the extent that it is regarded as a demerit. ;)

    2 Replies
    1. re: Perilagu Khan

      I agree! Taking healthiness out of the categories!

      1. re: Vivalish

        (Will these treads be combined?)

    2. I don't think juiciness should be part of it. As kids we used to steal the balls right out if the bowl after frying. Unless they all plan to soak em in sauce it doesn't make sense plus if you are judging the ball everyone better use the same sauce or it is completely unfair.

      1. If you think taste is most important then...
        Taste - 40
        Texture - 20
        Creativity - 20
        Appearance -20
        With an extra 10 points for sauce pairing.
        Are you limiting it to type? Like Italian, Swedish, Asian; or anything goes?
        I like the word "creative" better than "unique" as creative can be unique, and unique can be, well, just bad. ha!
        Also, "juiciness" level can depend on the type of meatball, so think that "texture" covers that aspect.
        I like dealing with round numbers, like a 100 pt. scale, with the extra points going for the one that goes the extra yard.

        8 Replies
        1. re: wyogal

          Thanks so much for your suggestion!

          @melpy, agreed about the juiciness
          @wyogal I was thinking of opening it up to all types. And I think texture does cover juiciness.

          1. re: Vivalish

            Are veg and tofu balls allowed? Not that I'd recommend it, mark you.

            1. re: Vivalish

              Maybe not, about equating texture to juiciness. Some types of meatballs, say Italian, have an open texture which makes juiciness easier. Other types, say Scandanavian or British, tend to be much denser which, IMO, concentrates the flavour. Judges will have to decide which texture they prefer

              1. re: Harters

                exactly. Texture would be as in appropriate to the specific meatball. Scores higher if the Italian style has the right texture for Italian, and the Swedish has the right texture for Swedish. It's all subjective anyway, but I thought that "texture" was more adaptable to type than "juiciness." I didn't equate them. That's why I chose the word texture over juiciness.

                1. re: wyogal

                  Indeed. I rather like your scoring suggestion, although I'm not sure about the "creativity". Might that mean that points would be scored for a creative Swedish ball but nothing for a traditional? Could be problematical.

                  1. re: Harters

                    yeah. not sure that it should even be included. Because a trad meatball can be very good.
                    If I got "creative" with my Swedish meatballs, the family would revolt! ha!

                    1. re: wyogal

                      Let's jointly suggest dropping the creativity and subbing in the sauce?

                      Although this only works if all meatballs, of whichever national origin, have a sauce or gravy? I'd like to hope that they do. Even the canape sized ones I've been known to make have a ketchup based dipping sauce with them.

          2. I think you're making it too complicated. My friends and I do competitions like this all the time and in my experience adding other categories only serves to complicate the judging...Unless you have a really good reason to judge in multiple categories, I think it's best to just go by taste.

            1. You must eat four meatballs. One from each of your friends. The fourth is your choice. Whichever one you choose is the winner.

              It doesn't have to be more complicated than that.