HOME > Chowhound > Minneapolis-St. Paul >
What are you cooking today?

Sauerkraut that's too mild :-(

Enso Jan 7, 2012 09:37 AM

We no longer eat wheat in my family, but have fond memories of reuben sandwiches, so I tried a reuben soup recipe. The sauerkraut seemed way too weak/mild and so the soup lacked good flavor.

Can you recommend a sauerkraut with a more intense flavor than average? (but maybe not to the level of knock-your-socks-off)

  1. s
    shoo bee doo Jan 10, 2012 08:08 AM

    I would have added the sauerkraut at the last minute or even once the soup has cooled down a little. That way it would retain its enzymic value plus not have all the flavor cooked out of it.

    1 Reply
    1. re: shoo bee doo
      GutGrease Jan 10, 2012 10:06 AM

      That's a GREAT point about adding it near or at the end of the soup process. I have to do that with garlic when I make meals, so that the flavor doesn't cook out.

    2. e
      Enso Jan 10, 2012 04:04 AM

      Thanks for all the input so far.

      -Can't make S. from scratch.

      -Did use canned; will try bagged next time.

      -Thought about adding a bit of vinegar to leftovers, but was afraid it would make it curdle, which would be too undesirable (cream and cheese, ya know).

      -Ak-mak do have wheat. And, unfortunately, any non-wheat cracker hits another limit for us: too high carb per volume.

      -Will see if the nearby coops and psuedo-coops have alternatives. What would I look for on the label to know it's tangy-er/more sour? Does real sauerkraut have vinegar in it?

      -Heartland sounds interesting, but is too far from my stompin' grounds.

      1 Reply
      1. re: splatgirl
        ajb05854 Jan 10, 2012 09:52 AM

        I grew up eating lots of kraut fermented in 50 gallon crocks. Bubbies is the closest I've seen to homemade.

      2. g
        GutGrease Jan 9, 2012 07:57 AM

        I do find that the bagged kraut available all Cub/Rainbow is better than the canned variety.

        1. b
          Brad Ballinger Jan 8, 2012 05:24 PM

          Attempting to keep this thread on this board and not something like home cooking...

          The sauerkraut for sale at Heartland's market is, in a word, fantastic. It's not going to have as much vinegar "kick" as sometihng purchased from a can or refrigerated bag, but it will have more depth and complexity of flavor.

          1. s
            steve_in_stpaul Jan 8, 2012 04:23 PM

            I'm not generally a fan of canned sauerkraut; it doesn't taste as fresh (?) to me. The plastic-bagged variety is readily available at most grocery stores (usually sold in the meat department). An alternative that I really like (though it is not inexpensive) is the jarred sauerkraut from Angelica's Garden. I can buy it at my coop, Mississippi Market.

            1. splatgirl Jan 7, 2012 05:22 PM

              Are you talking about authentic, lacto fermented sauerkraut, or the canned kind?
              If you can make it yourself, do so (cabbage, salt a vessel and time). The length of time it is allowed to ferment determines it's potency.
              As far as canned goes, I like the kind with the green label--"Kraut"--name is escaping me--but find that there's really nothing like real, old fashioned sauerkraut made as above.
              Reuben soup sounds interesting--maybe you could add more acid or something to pump up the sauerkrautish flavor element?
              I have a reuben dip recipe that is awesome. It's just your typical reuben ingredients mixed up and melty in a crock pot, typically eaten on cocktail rye or crackers, but you could figure out a non-wheat vehicle I'm sure. (Do ak-mak crackers contain wheat?)

              Show Hidden Posts