HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Adventures in Vanilla Extract Making

gothamette Jan 2, 2012 09:09 AM

Elsewhere, I asked which is the best, cheapest tasteless vodka for making home-made vanilla extract. I got a lot of responses, including several to use more higher proof grain alcohol, and bourbon or rum. I ended up using a cheap Polish vodka (Wodka) because it was cheap, came in a big bottle, and was there. I just don't buy the vodka snob thing. It's vodka. I only want something that tastes like nothing.

I then searched around for vanilla extract recipes and methods and was confused by the lack of specificity. Most of them didn't give specific ratios.

Then I got lucky, and found this website:


I highly recommend it if you are interested in making vanilla extract. He gives fairly exact proportions. His vanilla bean to alcohol ratio is quite a bit higher than most, and his reasons are good. Also, he says that it'll take 6 months for a proper extract to be created. This all sounds quite right to me. I never believed that you'll have a usable vanilla extract in a month, and that you can put two or three vanilla beans in 8 ounces of alcohol and have a real product.

Also, somewhere in the pages, which are chock-full of vanilla wisdom, someone claims that a higher proof doesn't necessarily make a better extract. I am not a chemist so I don't know for sure, but commercial vanilla extracts are 35% alcohol, and vodka is 40% alcohol. Perhaps using 90% alcohol (Everclear, Bak Spiritus) damages the delicate chemicals that are necessary to make a great vanilla.

In any case if you love vanilla, the Vanilla Review is your go-to site.

Disclaimer: I don't know the guy, and get no kickbacks.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. c
    Chocomom RE: gothamette Jan 2, 2012 09:19 AM

    Thanks, I've been wanting to make my own vanilla extract since I'd gotten 4oz of beans as a gift. Like you I'd looked online and couldn't get a clear recipe esp which kind of alcohol to use.

    1 Reply
    1. re: Chocomom
      gothamette RE: Chocomom Jan 2, 2012 10:56 AM

      In looking over the links I provided, I see that you can get 25 Mad. Bourbons for $16.50 (shipping included). Wow. These are the best beans, and I think they throw in a freebie as well. Maybe I should have gotten that. Maybe I will. I've gone a bit nutty about this.

    2. momskitchen RE: gothamette Jan 2, 2012 09:26 AM

      Where did you buy your beans....my usual purveyor http://www.organic-vanilla.com/servle... has been out of stock for a while now.

      3 Replies
      1. re: momskitchen
        gothamette RE: momskitchen Jan 2, 2012 10:52 AM

        I got my first batch from a source that I don't want to name because I'm not sure of the policy on these boards regarding criticism. They were good beans (although I am NO expert) and they came quickly, but I found a cheaper source via the link I supplied.


        I have ordered a 2nd batch but not via the above link , because you have to order too much for my experimental tastes. If I keep this up, I'll buy a larger quantity from them, splitting half with a friend.

        So, I bought these:


        A dozen was enough, and the price and shipping were right. (Hint: this was $6 cheaper than the first batch I bought.


        I'll let you know how it turns out. I've got enough vodka in that 1.5 ltr bottle to make quite a bit.

        Good luck!

        (Read Ian's pages very carefully in any case - they are treasure troves of vanilla wisdom.)

        PS - in my upcoming batch, I'm not going to scrape out the 'caviar'. I'm going to split open the beans, chop them into 1/2 inch pieces, and put those into the vodka-filled jar. Scraping out the 'caviar' is messy and there is always a tiny bit of wastage, which even if it's small, bothers me. I am such a cheapskate! I sincerely believe that after 6 months of macerating and shaking, the caviar will successfully dislodge from the inner skin of the bean. In any case, it is worth an experiment, and my 2nd batch is cheap enough.

        1. re: gothamette
          HillJ RE: gothamette Jan 2, 2012 12:02 PM


          Here's what a few of your fellow CH's had to say on the quest for vanilla bean deliciousness. Watch the CHOW video and check out the links for some wonderfully affordable v bean sources.

          1. re: HillJ
            gothamette RE: HillJ Jan 2, 2012 01:49 PM

            Thanks for the video link! I'll try it. But I'll use the vodka I have on hand instead of the rum she suggests. I'm always interested in different techniques.

      2. g
        gothamette RE: gothamette Jan 2, 2012 03:11 PM

        This looks like a promising technique:

        Food processor?

        "Although not so pretty as the sliced beans (and i’m just supposing, i haven’t tried this either way). Why not do a rough chop on the beans, then put them in the food processor… add in the vodka bit by bit, and when you’ve got a pretty smashed up slurry, funnel it into the bottle. Then probably top off with more vodka (my food processor is quite tiny)."


        1. t
          travelerjjm RE: gothamette Jan 2, 2012 03:45 PM

          If you want your vodka to taste a bit cleaner, run it through a charcoal water filter (like one of the jugs) two or three times. People who use it as a base for home made liqueurs (by adding little jars of flavoring) do this and sear by it. I did not do this for vanilla extract as I prefer the rum-based version.

          1 Reply
          1. re: travelerjjm
            gothamette RE: travelerjjm Jan 2, 2012 05:40 PM

            I wouldn't bother. A home water filter isn't going to do anything more than a commercial distiller. Just buy a decent brand of tasteless vodka. Or go the rum route as you did.

          2. iL Divo RE: gothamette Jan 2, 2012 04:05 PM

            love the looks of this very easy recipe.
            I think we could all do this if waiting isn't a problem and you're not in a hurry.
            just trying to figure out how many vanilla beans you'd need or I should say I'd need to buy.
            got the vodka.

            1 Reply
            1. re: iL Divo
              gothamette RE: iL Divo Jan 2, 2012 05:41 PM

              The link gives the number of vanilla beans to ounces or cups or ml of vodka.

              And yes, you do need to be patient. The author says you have usable extract in a month but it's not really real until after 6 months.

              It's a long term project, a life-long hobby. It's like wine-making.

            2. iL Divo RE: gothamette Nov 30, 2012 11:32 AM

              yesterday I bought bourbon, rum and vodka for the holidays.
              I also bought them because I have the vanilla beans now thanks to those on CH.
              so, vanilla making is today.
              one recipe tells exactly how many beans to how much alcohol.
              3 beans to 1 cup.
              that's easy enough. the recipe on the link above says 1 oz or 30 grams of beans to 1 cup alcohol. so if I get out the kitchen scale and I will, I'll see if it equals the 3 beans the other recipe says.

              I'm going to do one batch vodka labeled, one batch bourbon labeled, one batch rum labeled.
              that way I'll know which to use for what. < plus I have all this booze so gotta make use of it.

              4 Replies
              1. re: iL Divo
                chefathome RE: iL Divo Nov 30, 2012 12:15 PM

                You'll love 'em all. I've done this for years and love that you can just keep on topping up the jars with alcohol and throw in your used vanilla beans. I would say about 3 beans per cup sounds right.

                1. re: chefathome
                  iL Divo RE: chefathome Nov 30, 2012 05:20 PM

                  yep, after doing a little popping around web sites and with the help of ones on here, it sounded correct. they're all made now and I must say, that was fun. scraping those puppies was harder than I thought because some are drier than others that are plump and moist.
                  but I managed and they're all labeled and in the very dark wine/alcohol dark cold hiding place:)

                  1. re: iL Divo
                    chefathome RE: iL Divo Nov 30, 2012 07:23 PM

                    Ha! Now you are headed straight for addiction like me. Wonder which you'll prefer!?

                    1. re: iL Divo
                      gothamette RE: iL Divo Dec 22, 2012 09:15 AM

                      You don't need to scrape the beans. Chopping to smaller pieces helps a bit, but if you macerate them in alcohol for at least six months scraping is unnecessary. It's really a waste of time.

                      I ran across another tip that helped: if you have a mini-food processor, or any kind of blender/chopper, put the beans in there with half cup of liquid alcohol of your choice and whirl away. Dump/scrape proceeds into vessel, add more alcohol, and wait. And wait. And wait.

                Show Hidden Posts