Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > New Jersey >
Dec 26, 2011 10:37 AM

Mercer Street Grill in Hightstown - anyone try it yet? (with fun backstory!)

So there's a new venture in this location, which has to be one of the more doomed spots for a restaurant that I've ever seen. When I first got to Hightstown the place was the Slow Down Cafe, a mysterious coffee joint that was barely open (I think it was only open weekdays 9-4 p.m., seriously). That eventually went under, and was replaced with - of all things - a Thai noodle place, called Da's Thai Noodles.

When Da's opened all you had to do was glance at it and you knew it was never going to last. The owners did very little to change the decor from the previous use, so it looked like the Slowdown suddenly went under new management and added Thai food to the coffeehouse menu. Apparently the owners felt the location was too small to be successful, and they've since moved to Hopewell.

Which leads us to the mysterious Mercer Street Grill. No website yet. It's closed Mondays. My wife and I have peered through the windows, and it looks like it's a New American cuisine attempt with emphasis on steaks. The restaurant is TINY so I'm highly skeptical that this is going to last. I mean, you don't really think of downtown Hightstown when you're in the mood for steaks, do you?

One of the fascinating things about this location is that years ago, a woman was murdered in the apartment above the restaurant. My wife thinks the location has been subsequently cursed/haunted. Now personally I think haunted food tastes better but I haven't mustered up the courage to try Mercer Street Grill. So any info would be appreciated!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. The original comment has been removed
    1. Why aren't the comments showing up?

      1 Reply
      1. re: wereboar

        I've been 3-4 times, good food, great service, people eating at 3pm weekday- in the rain in- January. Best Cuban sandwich south of Hudson County. *Fire Grill* steaks in Hightstown!

        Do you actually go into these places or only do drive-by reviews?

      2. Went here last night - this place is a winner. It's Portuguese-style BBQ, like the places on Ferry Street in Newark. We had a rack of pork ribs, which were delicious. They were marinated in Brown Sugar, Cumin, and other spices before cooking. These aren't fall-off-the-bone-style low-and-slow ribs (which is a good thing in this case). We also had a Skirt Steak, which was perfectly seasoned and cooked. Desserts (coconut cake and homemade flan) were surprisingly good.

        2 Replies
        1. re: cranrob

          Cranrob, since your posts are all on the money, I am going to take the family here soon to try it, since we live 5 minutes away. I have been disappointed with Tavern on the Lake lately (new chef I guess), so will see how they do here.

          1. re: jethro

            Thank you Jethro... I went back to take out some of their grilled chicken. When I arrived to pick it up, they were just getting the charcoal grill going, and I saw them reheating my chicken, which I guess was cooked earlier, in the microwave (!!!). It was still very good (and still moist), but I can imagine how much better it would have been if it was grilled-to-order.

            So, I suggest calling first to make sure their grill is fired up before heading over.

            Another (small) nit: They have Tabasco on the tables, but in the kitchen they have the more traditional "Piri-Piri" sauce, which the places in Newark serve with their meals, and is so much better on the grilled items. When we asked, they gladly gave us some for our table.

        2. We have been there three times. Once for breakfast, the other for lunch. Each time our meals have been really good. The BBQ wings special on my last visit were the best I've had anywhere around here. The interior has gotten a nice makeover since the last restaurant left. The staff is very friendly.

          1. Cuban sandwich was excellent!