HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Discussion

okay to use these eggs?

  • 7

I have 3 eggs in my fridge that are a few days past their date and I want to hard-cook them. I did the floating-in-water test with them--they "stand on end" in the water but still stay at the bottom of the pot, not floating. Do you think they are okay?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
    1. I do that test also. Mainly because I gather my eggs from my Aunt's house and there is always a chance that an egg was damaged and can't be seen with the naked eye. If an egg float's, it indicate's air in the egg and it should immediately be discarded.

      I am curious why you think that they should float in the pot? I would immediately throw out any eggs that floated in the pot, too. Actually, if you are already boiling them you could drop the first step and just do the water in the pot test :-)

      2 Replies
      1. re: Robinez

        I DON'T think they should float in the pot. If they floated, I would have thrown them away. My concern was that they didn't sink enough, since they were standing on their ends at the bottom, which very fresh eggs don't do. My hunch was that they're fine, and others seem to agree.

        1. re: Lady_Tenar

          I appologize.

          When you said that the egg's "stand on end" in the water but still stay at the bottom of the pot, not floating" ,

          I assumed that you were concerned why they were still staying at the bottom of the pot and not floating.

        1. I never look at the date on my eggs and they're always okay.

          1. Yes, they are fine, especially if you hard boil them!

            if they float they should be thrown