Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Dec 3, 2011 08:53 AM

Non-Chocolate Guinness cake?

Long story short I only eat chocolate as a gift (I won't pay for it). Last year, someone gave me a chocolate Guinness cake for my birthday and it was AWESOME (actually it was an Irish car-bomb cake, it was brushed with Jameson syrup and had Baileys butter cream frosting). The Guinness gave the cake a lovely texture and flavor, which was offset nicely by the chocolate, but the Guinness was the dominant flavor.

I've been interested in baking another Guinness cake, but without chocolate. I'm wondering if chow hounds think it would even be good. I don't want to go the carob thing, but I'm wondering what else I would pair with the Guinness. Salted caramel maybe to offset the bitterness? Almond came to mind, not sure why. Orange maybe? Or do you think a Guinness cake could stand on it's own without another flavor.

Looking around the internet I only find a few Guinness cake recipe without chocolate, and they seems more like a quick bread with lots of dried fruit and spices in it, which wasn't really what I was looking for. I wanted something a little more cakey, and the spices (cinnamon and nutmeg mostly) might be good but not so sure about the dried fruit.

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I have had Irish Car Bomb Ice Cream that was a Guinness base w/ a Baileys caramel swirl and it was VERY good.

    1. Gramercy tavern gingerbread. Insanely good.

      2 Replies
      1. re: girlwonder88

        +1 on the Gramercy Gingerbread - in fact, now that the thought of it is taunting me, maybe I'll go start some right now :)

        1. re: another_adam

          +1 from me, too. I made it once for a class. I was unsure how a group of 18-20 year olds (who tend to be picky, in my experience) would react--but they devoured it in no time flat.

      2. The difference between cakes and quick breads is not that clear. Cakes are sweet, but some quick breads and muffins are nearly as sweet. Quick breads are baked in loaf pans, but cakes can also be done that way (e.g. pound cake).

        There is a 'muffin method' of mixing - mix the dry, mix the wet, combine
        and 'cake method' - cream the butter and sugar, add the eggs, add the dry
        but there are muffin recipes that used the cake method, and cake recipes that use the muffin method (esp. mixes). The cake method is supposed to produce a more tender and uniform crumb.

        The gingerbread is a good example of using a dark beer in a sweet and moist cake/bread.

        1. i made this oatmeal cake that calls for a dark beer like Guinness. I used oatmeal milk stout. It was for a breakfast meeting and people really liked it.

          I'm not sure if it's what you're looking for though because the oatmeal gave it a heavier texture. Not as cakey.

          The flavor was very good. And was even better the next day.

          1 Reply
          1. re: karykat

            that sounds wonderful. I love oat flavor and it seems like this cake would bring it out. Thanks.