HOME > Chowhound > Greater Boston Area >

olive oil?

barleywino Nov 17, 2011 07:40 AM

Anybody have a favorite olive oil (and where to find it in Boston area)? TIA

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. e
    emannths RE: barleywino Nov 17, 2011 08:05 AM

    I like the Kirkland stuff in the 1L glass bottles from Costco. It's about $10/L, and very nice for general use--very "olive-y" aromatically, and not particularly buttery or peppery.

    8 Replies
    1. re: emannths
      lovethatdirtywater RE: emannths Nov 17, 2011 09:01 AM

      Kirkland just changed its Tuscany house brand which was fantastic for the price, now their house brand is a new bottle and labelled Kirkland/Filippo Berio...

      1. re: lovethatdirtywater
        emannths RE: lovethatdirtywater Nov 17, 2011 09:09 AM

        Last time I was there (Aug, I think), they had both the Tuscany one, in liter glass bottles, and the co-branded Kirkland/Berio one in larger plastic bottles. Did they really discontinue the Tuscany one, or could it have been OOS or hidden?

        1. re: emannths
          Highland Park RE: emannths Nov 17, 2011 10:28 AM

          The Kirkland Signature Toscano olive oil with grower ID and origin stamp is an excellent quality and flavorful oil, particularly for Italian cooking (obviously). It is not discontinued. It is sold out for the season and should return once the current harvest wraps up and the new oil is produced. Hopefully it will reappear in February, at least that's what the Costco manager tells me. It is a bargain at that price and will sell out again no doubt, so stock up when it reappears.

          1. re: Highland Park
            jhfrontz RE: Highland Park Dec 10, 2011 10:40 AM

            I'm SO glad to hear that -- I talked to a couple of Costco folks on the sales floor a week or so ago and they lamented the lack of olive oil packed in anything but plastic. Apparently a lot of folks had been asking about "the olive oil in glass bottles" and all the staff knew was that they were out of it. I'll definitely have to stock up when the next batch comes in!

            1. re: jhfrontz
              Highland Park RE: jhfrontz Dec 10, 2011 11:49 AM

              It seems as though WF is now stocking an olive oil from the same Toscano grower as the Costco one. Its not in the 365 line, but rather just says Whole Foods on it. It is a cylindrical bottle of 23.5 ounces and sells for 12.99. Not the same deal as the Costco 32 ounces for 9.99, but not bad. I picked up a bottle of that and the Columela in Bedford on Monday.

              1. re: Highland Park
                Highland Park RE: Highland Park Jan 26, 2012 06:59 AM

                The 2011 harvest of the Toscano is now available at Costco. The price is $11.99/liter, a little higher than last year but still a good deal. I picked up 4 bottles of it in Nashua on Saturday. They had quite a bit of it in stock.

                1. re: Highland Park
                  emannths RE: Highland Park Jan 26, 2012 07:06 AM

                  W00t! I assume this will again be around till at least mid summer, so there's no need for me to go out and buy a year's supply before then, right?

                  1. re: emannths
                    Highland Park RE: emannths Jan 26, 2012 07:17 AM

                    Possibly. My experience is that the Nashua and Dedham stores hold onto this stock longer than say Waltham, but lots of people do know about the value in this product and even more so than last year.

    2. d
      DoubleMan RE: barleywino Nov 17, 2011 08:32 AM

      Aria is really great and for sale at a number of places. It is about $12 for a 500mL bottle. You can get a 3L can at Formaggio for $42. It's not a cheap oil, but it's good enough for dressings and even finishing, but not too expensive to be wasted on cooking.

      Olive Harvest is a great Lebanese brand that you can get in bottles of all sizes for not too much. I've seen it at the Watertown armenian stores.

      1. r
        rouxmaker RE: barleywino Nov 17, 2011 08:48 AM

        Armenian stores in Watertown (Mt. Auburn St) is the best selection and value. They run about $30 for a 3L can or bottle with selections from Lebanan, Greece, etc.

        1. yumyum RE: barleywino Nov 17, 2011 10:12 AM

          I have a cheap (everyday) suggestion and a spendy (special treat) idea for you:

          For cheap and cheerful, I use Trader Joe's olive oil. Great value for a very satisfactory frying / cooking oil. It's not a finishing oil for me.

          For special treat olive oil, I bought a bottle of Frantoi Cutrera "Segreto" extra virgin at Salumeria Italiana. Costly but IMO worth every penny. The essence of green and slightly peppery olives. Fantastic!

          Salumeria Italiana
          151 Richmond St, Boston, MA 02109

          Trader Joe's
          1427 Massachusetts Ave, Arlington, MA 02476

          3 Replies
          1. re: yumyum
            cambridgedoctpr RE: yumyum Nov 17, 2011 11:31 AM

            i like French EVOOs, but Columella that is available at Whole Foods won the blind tasting at Cook's Illustrated.


            EVOO Restaurant
            350 Third Street, Cambridge, MA 02143

            1. re: cambridgedoctpr
              mikeinboston RE: cambridgedoctpr Nov 18, 2011 05:48 PM

              Columela is also available from Amazon in a 2 pack, ships for free. Outstanding.

              1. re: mikeinboston
                cbjones1943 RE: mikeinboston Dec 22, 2011 11:05 PM

                I have used OO from Medi Terra and have mostly been more than satisfied Do not usually spend the extra $$ for "cold-pressed" Have been using Columela Spain for some time now The one with cork topper I purchase mine in Harris Teeter. I'm actually responding to share something I recently learned about Spanish OO Maybe all OO Ate several-course lunch prepared by high-end cook from Spain. The OO used for frying or otherwise preparing dishes was the most heavenly I've ever had. Spanish OO has the reputation of being more acidic than most others. I like the stronger taste Short end of story is that the cook told me that in Spain My type of Columela EVOO is used only for salads Not cooking The next time I recall I will post information about the type she uses

          2. Bob Dobalina RE: barleywino Nov 17, 2011 12:13 PM

            We're fans of Capone's store brand and we bring our refillable bottle back regularly. Use it mostly for non-heated applications, finishing, etc.

            2 Replies
            1. re: Bob Dobalina
              ipsofatso RE: Bob Dobalina Nov 17, 2011 01:16 PM

              I believe Capone's is shipped in from Napa Valley Olive Oil Co, Helena, CA and re-sold as their brand. Which of course, they are free to do. NVOO Co will ship bulk orders (5 gallons +) and it is truly devise stuff, just be sure its the EVOO. I like that and the Costco Tuscan stamped is a great value.

              1. re: Bob Dobalina
                lipoff RE: Bob Dobalina Nov 18, 2011 09:38 PM

                I like Capone's store brand as well, and use it for similar purposes. One of things I like a lot about Capone's is that they have a number of different olive oils available for tasting, along with some little cubes of (good) bread. If you are in the market for olive oil, I'd recommend going there to try a few different varieties to see yourself what you like best.

              2. StevieC RE: barleywino Nov 17, 2011 01:01 PM

                Frantoia (Sicily) and Lucini (Tuscany) EVOO are excellent and widely available, even in Stop & Shop.

                Both were regularly used by Mario Batali in his Molto Mario shows, even when he touted using oil from the region of that episode's cooking (and it wasn't Sicily or Tuscany).

                1. kobuta RE: barleywino Nov 17, 2011 06:31 PM

                  The Fruit Center Market Place in East Milton Square has a lovely selection of olive oils in their prepared foods section, by the cheeses and vinegars. I bought a nice bottle of Iliada Greek EVOO that was had a nice herbaceous taste (if you like that), but they had many varieties.

                  EVOO Restaurant
                  350 Third Street, Cambridge, MA 02143

                  1. calisson RE: barleywino Dec 1, 2011 08:02 PM

                    I am very fond of the refillable Ariston Greek olive oil you can find at Pemberton Market (Cambridge), When Pigs Fly bakeries (Somerville, Brookline, JP), and the Village Cheese Shop (Roslindale Village). It's probably in other spots as well.
                    The Ariston balsamic vinegar is really good too. And the Trader Joe's Greek olive oil is quite lovely. I found the special Kirkland Signature Toscano olive oil from Costco too peppery for my taste.

                    1 Reply
                    1. re: calisson
                      DrMag RE: calisson Jan 26, 2012 01:05 PM

                      They carry this at the Meathouse in Brookline. It is my new favorite olive oil for drizzling on things

                    2. threedogs RE: barleywino Dec 10, 2011 12:03 PM

                      Olympic extra virgin - this has become my standard olive oil. I bought mine at Marty's in Newton, but their site says they sell it at lots of other places, including Russo's, WF's & Formaggio's. Not terribly expensive, either.

                      1 Reply
                      1. re: threedogs
                        threedogs RE: threedogs Jan 26, 2012 07:32 AM

                        Arax and Seven in Watertown are now carrying Olympic. I paid $30 for a three liter can - still have lots of love for this oil.

                      2. w
                        weg RE: barleywino Dec 23, 2011 08:18 AM

                        I received Trasimeno Mills Organic Extra-Virgin Olive Oil as a gift a few years ago from my Dad and we have been using it ever since. (the importer lives out in WMass in my Dad's home town). It is pricey, but delicious - -especially for salads and drizzled over vegetables. It has a long shelf life. Website is:

                        Otherwise, we use use the Costco extra virgin, and the lighter Filip Berio for higher temp cooking.

                        1. s
                          sunalso RE: barleywino Jan 27, 2012 08:03 AM

                          I also have really liked Olympic for my everyday olive oil. Everyone should know that they (Extra Virgin Foods) are at the Wayland Winter Farmer's Market on Saturdays, and are selling 2 more oils in addition to the bottled stuff. These two new and fresh oils are phenomenal and worth the ride and the $$ (you pay for the bottle, then it's refillable next time...) I prefer the organic one, and the other was excellent with a bit of a pepper bite - I was told that this would age in the bottle and mellow.

                          Best I've ever had, maybe with one exception of a taste of one in Spain, but maybe not!

                          3 Replies
                          1. re: sunalso
                            threedogs RE: sunalso Jan 27, 2012 08:11 AM

                            Arrgh! I can't get to Wayland - are these two new oils offered by Olympic? If so, maybe they're selling these in other locations (I'd contact them directly to find out).

                            1. re: threedogs
                              sunalso RE: threedogs Jan 27, 2012 08:35 AM

                              too bad! yes, contact Extra Virgin Foods. My understanding is that they're the ones who bottle the Olympic, and that these 2 new ones are not being bottled/sold retail. Maybe they can tell you where else you can get to try these fresh treats.

                              1. re: sunalso
                                Vanderjane RE: sunalso Jan 27, 2012 02:48 PM

                                Letting the "cat out of the bag" that Costco now has the Kirkland Extra Virgin Olive oil Toscano, Oct/Nov 2011 Harvest in the glass 2 litre bottles. At least they did in Waltham and i bought a case. So happy as this is good stuff for $12 a litre!

                          2. almansa RE: barleywino Jan 27, 2012 04:20 PM

                            DaMorgada at Whole Foods is a personal favorite. I also like Liohori and Iliada. I'd recommend any of those for fans of Provencale oils.

                            Show Hidden Posts