Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Nov 15, 2011 06:14 PM

Get rid of yeast smell/taste in dough products

So, I know how to make bread and dough products appropriately.

What I don't get is, everytime I make anything like that, the yeast smell is in the bread, instead of the rich, wonderful bread smell (like when you get really good bread - I get it at Kings here in New Jersey). You know that smell when you open up the yeast packet or jar? The whole bread smells/tastes like that.
Also I can't get the slight sourness, and just the rich taste in general that comes with a good bread

So what is it that bakers do, yeast-wise, to make such good bread when it's really good?
Is it that they use that fresh yeast cake stuff? Instant yeast? Is it that I have to use a starter - the flour-water-yeast mixture you leave for a few days?

What is it? Anybody know?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. What recipe are you using? Are you doing a long ferment?

    2 Replies
    1. re: SnackHappy

      just normal twice rise plus pre-bake bench proof, using the normal active dry yeast. The yeast that you proof with warm water and sugar

      1. re: peanuttree

        I don't know what normal is to you. How much yeast are you using and for how much flour?

    2. Use less yeast and a long slow rise. More time develops more flavors, especially if you retard your dough in the refrigerator overnight. Some sourness develops, but also just complexity. Try taking a recipe you know works, use half the yeast, and refrigerate the dough for the first rise for at least 12 hours. A starter can definitely help with flavor development and getting some sourness in there. You may even be able to use 1/4 the yeast if your original recipe had way to much.

      1. Yeast-flour-yeast mixture you leave for a few days.............not quite sure what you are talking about unless you are working on some kine of sour dough? We make bread every other day, each time we do it in half a day.

        1 Reply
        1. re: escondido123

          Biga is one name for it, others call it a chef or poolish or pre-ferment. It is not necessarily at room temp for days, but can last in the fridge for a few to add flavor. There is also the old dough method, where if you make bread regularly, you save back a bit of the dough and add it to the next batch, and keep going and going. All may have slightly different definitions/formulations, but same basic concept of time = flavor. It's not just about wild yeasts and developing sourness, there are enzymatic reactions with the flour that take place over time. Sorry I can't explain more, that's the gist of what I've read, I'm no expert.

        2. As others are saying, you want a long slow rise with less commercial yeast to get rid of the "raw" yeast aroma. To develop the sour flavor you're looking for you want to develop an old dough. That means that you pull off a handful when you next make dough. Put that in a sealed container in your fridge. Next time you make dough, take it out of the fridge, cut it into small pieces and throw it in with whatever other ingredients, remembering to pull off another handful and store it.

          To get a good overview of the use and scope of pre-ferments "Rustic European Bread from Your Bread Machine" by Linda West Eckhardt and Diana Collingwood Butts is a very useful book whether or not you prefer to use a bread machine.

          2 Replies
          1. re: rainey

            One thing I've noticed reading older literature is that it sometimes refers to setting bread to rise the night before, and then getting up early to punch it down for the second rise. This makes sense in terms of this sort of baking - small amounts of yeast, or wild yeast, with a long, slow rise time, rather than the more modern approach of lost of yeast and a couple of hours total rise time. Plus, I suspect that without much in the way of indoor heating, the nighttime kitchen temperature was cool enough to slow the fermentation.

            1. re: tastesgoodwhatisit

              I think you're onto something with the cooler overnight temps. So many people today think you really need to put the dough in a warm location. I NEVER do that.

              An active dough will rise in a cold fridge. I use my microwave. Not turned on, of course, but at my house it has 2 advantages: it's an insulated box that will not dry out the dough at a neutral temperature and it keeps it safe from my dog who sees no advantage whatsoever to baking dough. Seriously, a microwave is a great proofing box and a great place to rest a roasted piece of meat.

          2. you're either leaving yeast in h2o too long or, more likely, your h2o is too hot or both; for good sour taste, find an aged sourdough starter from a good baker