Help! I've got a freezer full.
I treat the different cuts just as I would prepare Beef, except I have never grilled it in any shape or form.
Soaking some of the "lesser cuts" overnight in buttermilk greatly improves texture. I love Venison Burgers with the usual trimmings, but I add my seasonings to the meat before I shape the patties. Venison makes awesome Chili, Goulash, Pot roast etc. Sometimes I mix it with Pork /sausages or similar for additional flavor.
My husband, the hunter, grills the sliced tenderloins after marinating them overnight. They are scrumptious! He does that every year for his employees and even the ones who think they hate venison love them. Marinade: soy sauce, a sliced onion, fresh ginger, vegetable oil, water, and a clove or two of garlic.
Venision chili, yummmm!!! Also, once some venision stew meat inspired me to try making a stew that made use of other native North American ingedients. I braised the meat and included some cranberries and a touch of pure, grade B (much better!) maple syrup in the braise, which gave it a delicious sweet-tartness and a really complex flavor. I thickened the stew with gumbo file powder (ground, dried sassafras, a native plant) and I think I included a few juniper berries as one of the seasonings. I served it over polenta (because, you know, maize). It. Was. Awesome. You could use any of the tougher cuts, with plenty of connective tissue.
I also once had a goulash made with venison. It was pretty out-of-this world. Damn, I want a freezer full of venison too!
Venison is very lean compared to beef, so you need to be careful it doesn't dry out -- braising, larding -- anything to maintain the moisture levels. Tenderloins can be grilled, of course.
Lucky, lucky you.
One of my favorite recipes is a venison and Guinness stew with horseradish and mustard dumplings. I don't have access to venison and make it with beef, but it would be perfect for a braising cut of venison.
My uncle used to marinate venison ribs in a mustard-based sauce and grill. Not much meat on them but quite tasty.
I did a search to see if the recipe from my little UK cookbook was out there, and it was (lazy me was hoping not to type it all up)!
I make my own dumpling recipe and add horseradish, mustard and fresh thyme rather than going with the beef suet dumpling the recipe includes. I know juniper berries aren't a common ingredient in much cooking, but it is very worth getting when you have a freezer full of venison.
I hope you enjoy it.
I make pretty much anything you'd make with beef with venison, and it all works great. The only things you need to keep in mind are that venison A) cooks faster than beef if you are roasting or grilling or pan-frying the good cuts, and B) has a lot less fat, so you can add oil or butter as you choose, if you want to make up for this.
Steak au poivre is great with the tenderloins.
I like the lean quality of venison and have made many a pot of chili, Bolognese sauce, stew, goulash, etc. without adding much extra fat. Do not be afraid to substitute it for beef in most any recipe. If you have a pressure cooker this is a great way to use the less tender cuts.
Also if you have a grinder make your own burgers, ground meat, and sausage. For the latter you will need to add fat, though IMHO less than most recipes demand.
I love Marcella Hazan's Italian recipes and have used venison in her Bolognese sauce recipe, meatloaf, and polpettine (Italian meatballs).