Thompson's Cider Mill, Ossining
Haven't had one of their pies in a long while, but it's not sticking in my memory (so I'm going to have to assume it was not memorable - but I hope others can chime in with more recent and hopefully postive feedback!). I ADORE their cider and freeze several after the season's done. Best thing we bring to Thanksgiving with our family. If you get a pie, let us know how it turns out.