HOME > Chowhound > New York State (exc. NYC) >

Discussion

No. Westchester (P'ville/Chapp/Kisco) pre-HS reunion dinner?

  • 8

A few old friends need a quiet (but not dead) place to catch up and steel ourselves before going to a 25th high school reunion. Looking for something casual and affordable, more than a diner but less than a trendy bistro -- not too big, not too small, not too sedate, but not too hopping. We're meeting at 5.30pm and have a couple hours to kill. The old Vinny's in Pleasantville would fit the bill, but it's long gone. In addition to towns mentioned above, we could venture a little farther afield -- Briarcliff, Ossining, Bedford Hills, Thornwood, Hawthorne -- but don't want to get too far away. (Speaking of which: would the Hawthorn Ale House, mentioned recently in the NYT, fit the bill? That Kittle House pub also sounds great, but probably a bit posh for this outing.)

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. village social kisco, gordos hawthorne orfinos bcliff spacarellis millwood

    1. McArthur's in Pleasantville-- Pub food. Not sedate, and not hopping. Great for conversation. Should fit your bill.

      http://www.mcarthursamericangrille.co...

      3 Replies
      1. re: menton1

        Boy the people on Yelp generally can't stand the place -- say it's very expensive for what it is, and what it is is average at best. Obviously, you disagree. Why?

        http://www.yelp.com/biz/mcarthurs-ame...

        1. re: fmogul

          But we're not Yelp :-)

          I agree about McArthur's as fitting what you're talking about.

          Which night of the week are you talking about? It will be tough to find a hospitable place (besides a bar) to kill a few hours on a Friday night.

          If you're willing to go a bit further north, I recommend Umami in Croton.

          1. re: fmogul

            McArthur's is AWFUL. The food is worse than Friday's and the prices are so inflated it infuriates me.

            I think you should check out Pour, a wine bar in Mt. Kisco. I'd say Birdsall House in Peekskill but you requested quiet and I don't think BH qualifies as quiet, even at that early hour. Pour is a bit mor mellow, and it has great nibbles and a varied wine list. Also, according to their website, they take reservations for groups 8 and larger.

            http://www.pourmtkisco.com/

        2. Also in Chappaqua is Quaker Hill Tavern same idea but just smaller than MacArthurs. Also the Riviera in Pleasantville is a no frills Italian -food is good as are the prices and conducive to large groups

          -----
          Quaker Hill Tavern
          61 Bedford Rd, Chappaqua, NY 10514

          1. Nah, McArthur's isn't awful, it's Pub Food. Stick to a burger or something simple and you'll be fine. Burgers are about $12, Marinated Steak Sandwich, $15, Shepherd's Pie or Meatloaf entrees $16. All very good. It's not fine dining! But it fits the OP's request for a "not too sedate, not too hopping" perfectly! And a good place for conversation as well.

            1 Reply
            1. re: menton1

              how much are the burgers at horsefeathers in tarrytown please?
              thanks