HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >
Brewing beer, curing meat, or making cheese? Tell us about it

buttermilk pie variations

Hank Hanover Oct 14, 2011 07:49 PM

I am on vacation and just had dinner at the Branding Iron BBQ and Steak house in Mena, Arkansas. They had an interesting pie on their dessert menu. They called it "Bearcat Pie". I just had to ask what it was.

Apparently, it is a buttermilk pie with coconut and pecans added.

Now, I have never baked or even eaten a buttermilk pie but it is a custard pie made with sugar, buttermilk, eggs and flavorings (sometimes they add flour sometimes not) poured into a pie shell and baked.

This Bearcat pie had coconut and pecans added. Sadly, I didn't try the pie.

I was wondering if a buttermilk pie is any good. I assume it is. I was also wondering what other kinds of variations are there for buttermilk pie.

Have you chowhounders got any interesting variations?

  1. ipsedixit Oct 14, 2011 08:49 PM

    I really like this Sweet Potato Buttermilk Pie.

    And it's just perfect with Thanksgiving right around the corner.

    1. PotatoHouse Oct 15, 2011 05:07 AM

      Take it from a southerner, buttermilk pie is GREAT! It is also easy to make. You should try the pure form first, just so you know what it tastes like without add-ons, and then move on to other variations.

      1. paulj Oct 15, 2011 11:17 AM

        My favorite pie as a kid was sour cream raisin pie. This was a custard made with eggs, sour cream, brown sugar, and sweet spices (cinnamon etc), and lots of raisins. The raisins tended to settle, producing a mincemeat like lower layer, and pumpkin pie like top.

        I could see using buttermilk in place of the sour cream.

        1. p
          pine time Oct 15, 2011 11:22 AM

          Oh, do I have fond memories of my Mom making Buttermilk Pie while Dad sang "Buttermilk Sky." Haven't made that in years--thanks for reminding me!

          1. JungMann Oct 15, 2011 11:57 AM

            I can't recall if it started with the Louisiana side of my family or if my aunt clipped the recipe out of the paper, but buttermilk pie was an essential highlight of cold weather baking in my youth. It was the capstone to Christmas, and a snack between meals on Thanksgiving. As my aunt made it, buttermilk pie was classically Southern-sweet, with a strong taste of lemon rind and some cinnamon. Personally I prefer to reduce the sugar and lemon so that my filling is just this side of tangy with a hint of cinnamon.

            1. nomadchowwoman Oct 15, 2011 12:40 PM

              Here's the recipe I've used for years, Hank. It is based on an old Martha Stewart recipe, and it is delicious. I've never added anything to it, but I might do one w/the coconut and pecans this T-giving after reading your post. Sounds like a pretty good variation.

              Lemon Buttermilk Pie

              well-chilled 9-inch pie crust (I freeze it until I’m ready to fill it)


              1 ¼ c. sugar
              3 T flour
              4 lg. eggs, beaten
              ½ c. unsalted butter, melted
              1 ¼ c. buttermilk
              1 T lemon zest
              1 T lemon juice
              1 tsp. vanilla extract
              Freshly grated nutmeg to taste

              Preheat oven to 425F.

              Whisk sugar and flour in lg. bowl. Add eggs, and mix well. Stir in butter, buttermilk, lemon juice, lemon zest, vanilla, and nutmeg. Pour into pie shell. Place in center of oven for 15 minutes. After 15 minutes, reduce heat to 350. Bake another 35-40 minutes, until filling is set. (The middle will be slightly wobbly, and some melted butter may have pooled there; it will settle into the cooling pie.) Remove from oven; cool on rack. Serve at room temp.

              1. paulj Oct 15, 2011 01:37 PM

                For topics like this, Allrecipes can give you a lot of ideas. I don't think the recipes are carefully selected, so you need to select one with care (check the comments, and use your cooking sense)


                1. Hank Hanover Oct 15, 2011 03:33 PM

                  I have since found out why the restaurant called it bearcat pie. The bearcat is the mascot of the Mena high school football team. It looks like a panther to me.

                  1 Reply
                  1. re: Hank Hanover
                    jadec Oct 15, 2011 03:45 PM

                    I've used this recipe and added orange blossom water for a floral flavour: http://bakingbites.com/2010/06/butter...

                  Show Hidden Posts