Pane e Vino or Carmine in Providence

[bawc]

After living here 5 years, we have never been to either of these restaurants despite multiple visits on the hill. Which has better food? DH and I are in need of a casual night out and a movie, and the babysitter is all lined up! I am open to other suggestions, but we have already been to Constantino, Meditarreneo, Sieno Caserta, and the one with the train around the inside (can't remember the name).