HOME > Chowhound > Ontario (inc. Toronto) >
What are you cooking today?

Anyone remember the Prime Rib Sandwich place at Agincourt Mall that closed?

eatsalot2 Sep 27, 2011 11:03 PM

They had - bar none - the best prime rib sandwich I've ever had. It was a cafeteria-style joint in the mall and we used to go all the time when I was a kid. Amazing price too, I think just before it closed (maybe 7-10 yrs ago?) it was only about $8. This for 2 or 3 cuts of thicks slabs of juicy high-quality prime rib (they sometimes gave you the rib), with just the right amount of fat...with the bun dipped in the most amazing au jus. Place was a bit of a dive so that's why it was so shocking they had such an amazing sandwich (none of this shaved beef crap). I still get cravings for it...seriously it was better than the Harbour 60 version.

Does anyone know what happened to the place, did it move? There's some sort of full-service restaurant there now, would it still have the prime rib of the place before it? And if (sob) the place is really gone, does anyone have recommendations where I can get another juicy prime rib sandwich like that? (again not talking about the shaved stuff)

  1. m
    magic Sep 28, 2011 06:02 AM

    It is called Orchid Garden Deli. Best prime rib sammos ever!

    Has it closed?!?! What??

    I haven't been to Agincourt Mall in a good 5 years, but last time I was there it was still open. If they are indeed open I cannot see them taking that off the menu.

    They are still listed on the Agincourt Mall website:


    13 Replies
    1. re: magic
      Brain of J Sep 28, 2011 07:16 AM

      Called the number. They're still open.

      1. re: Brain of J
        magic Sep 28, 2011 07:23 AM

        Thanks!! I'll call and see if they're still serving the prime rib.

        eatsalot2, what makes you say they closed??

        1. re: magic
          eatsalot2 Sep 28, 2011 07:54 AM

          Thanks everyone for the replies, super helpful! So glad it's still there. Magic, I thought it was closed because last time I made a pilgrimage there (years back) they had this full-serve restaurant in its place. Now I know it's the same place, this Orchid Garden Deli, just renovated and full-service instead of caf-style.

          1. re: eatsalot2
            magic Sep 28, 2011 08:02 AM

            Phew, don't scare me like this!

            Haha, I do thank you for reminding me about Orchid Garden. Since I switched jobs I don't make it there that much. But thanks to you I think it's high time for a return! Hopefully the prime rib is still there....

            1. re: magic
              magic Sep 28, 2011 12:34 PM

              I called. They still have the prime rib. $9.32 with taxes for the sandwich.

              They also do meals, with rice and/or potatoes, and salad I think.

              Open weekends.

              1. re: magic
                eatsalot2 Sep 28, 2011 12:40 PM

                Awesome what a deal still. Gotta love Scarberia...I'll make the hour trek this weekend...so worth it! Thx

                1. re: eatsalot2
                  magic Sep 28, 2011 12:47 PM

                  As will I. No prob :)

                  1. re: magic
                    T Long Sep 29, 2011 12:15 PM

                    Please report back after your visits....I've walked by that place numerous times and never thought it was a hidden gem.

                    1. re: T Long
                      magic Sep 29, 2011 12:34 PM

                      Will do!

                      I haven't been in like 6 years but when I worked in the area I remember it being fantastic. Was always a treat.

                      Basic, but ever so good. You should try!

                      1. re: magic
                        neighborguy Oct 1, 2011 01:33 PM

                        I was in the area today and stopped in to check it out after this post piqued my curiosity, tho I generally stay away from this mall because of the Walmart. This place looks like a gem, maybe because it's cafeteria style. But it was busy, not expensive relative to the usual food-service outlets and the food looked, dare I say, real. There was a medium-looking prime rib sitting there on display ready for carving. Too bad I'd just eaten...

                        1. re: neighborguy
                          magic Oct 1, 2011 03:27 PM

                          Oh this place is indeed a gem. Beyond the prime rib I have no idea what their food is like - I never strayed beyond the prime rib sammo. But that item alone makes this place a gem. At least when I ate there way back when…..

                          1. re: magic
                            eatsalot2 Oct 2, 2011 07:43 PM

                            I went today and had it for the first time in probably a decade. I think they might cut it just slightly less thick than in the past, but otherwise, still as amazing as ever. The moist juicy meat, the amazing au jus - such a winner. If this was some hipster haunt DT, the price would probably be double. I'll be back soon

                            1. re: eatsalot2
                              magic Oct 2, 2011 08:07 PM

                              Excellent! Thanks for the report eatsalot2!!

                              Will be going very soon.

    2. t
      turntablejockey Sep 28, 2011 05:31 AM

      i do but i'm stuck too - don't know what happened and never found a comparable replacement to stop the jonesing

      Show Hidden Posts