Psst... We're working on the next generation of Chowhound! View >
HOME > Chowhound > Manhattan >
Sep 22, 2011 12:43 PM

Keens Steakhouse: Terrific Mutton Chops. Porterhouse Could Be Better. Now with Bacon!

As usual, full review with photos on the blog: http://ramblingsandgamblings.blogspot...

I was actually mildly surprised when I took a friend there recently to discover that even a place this old and steeped in history still tries to come up with something new on occasion. I'm talking about bacon.

A slab bacon appetizer was added to the menu about 4 months ago. While it wasn't quite as meaty as the bacon at Luger, it was still plenty flavorful. The accompanying tomatoes and greens went perfectly with the bacon, adding some nuttiness, bitterness, and acidity to counteract the feeling of shoving pure grease into your mouth.

The mutton chop is my favorite thing to get here. Cooked to a perfect medium (it still gets really red next to the bone), the meat is flavorful, the fat from the "chops" is luscious, and the homemade mint jelly goes great with it. As I was splitting this with a friend, they were nice enough to slice it off the bone for us.

This was my first time ordering the porterhouse for two. While the meat flavor was there, there wasn't really enough of a minerally, dry-aged tang to it. Also, serving it sliced and resting on a cutting board allowed it to dry out and get cold quickly. This is significantly inferior to the way Luger serves it, on a super hot plate and resting in its own drippings to stay moist.

While offering a range of steakhouse staples, the desserts manage to be fairly strong here. My friend loved his red berry bibble, shown here without the ice cream that usually accompanies it.

For my dessert, I had to have the coffee cantata. It's basically a sundae with coffee ice cream and some raspberry, and some very good fudge sauce. I mentioned to our server that I used to like their indian pudding, which they took off the menu a while back, and he replied that I was probably one of about five people who did.

I always highly recommend Keens, but I would definitely suggest sticking with the mutton chop over the porterhouse.

72 West 36th St., New York, NY 10018

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. Try the bacon at Club A Steakhouse. It's monumental/life changing.

    Club A Steakhouse
    240 East 58th Street, New York, NY 10022

    1. Keen's also has an excellent prime rib.

      1. Great review!

        You know, when I finally made it to Keens a couple years back, I gotta say their porterhouse didn't blow me away either. I would take the mutton chop over porterhouse, every time.

        What exactly is berry bibble, BTW? Google's not pulling up much.

        1 Reply
        1. re: uwsister

          I am not a sweets or desert guy but the bibble was one of the top deserts I have ever had.