HOME > Chowhound > Home Cooking >

Maximise protein and eliminate carbs in homemade yoghurt

k
Kiwi2011 Sep 19, 2011 03:16 AM

Hi Everyone,

How do I maximise the protein and eliminate the carbs in my homemade yoghurt?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
Delete
  1. biondanonima RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 19, 2011 08:08 AM

    Strain it, and strain it well. There will still be some carbs, but the more whey you remove, the more carbs you remove. I know some people also add protein powder to their milk when making yogurt, but I'm not sure how that affects the final texture and flavor.

    25 Replies
    1. re: biondanonima
      k
      Kiwi2011 RE: biondanonima Sep 19, 2011 08:11 AM

      Do you use full fat cows milk in yours?

      1. re: Kiwi2011
        k
        Kiwi2011 RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 19, 2011 08:20 AM

        Shouldn't the natural fermentation process eliminate all the carbs?,
        Should I add more yoghurt starter and leave it longer for this to work?

        1. re: Kiwi2011
          hotoynoodle RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 19, 2011 08:27 AM

          recent info now says that full-fat yogurt, like fage, is very very low-carb. much like cheese, the fermentation eats the lactose thereby reducing the carb count dramatically. the numbers on commercial labels are for the milk/cream before fermentation occurs. anyone know why the labeling works this way?

          so yes, strain out the whey for a greek-style yogurt, don't add fruit or sugar, and you'll have a very low-carb product.

          1. re: hotoynoodle
            k
            Kiwi2011 RE: hotoynoodle Sep 19, 2011 08:40 AM

            Thats fascinating, thank-you.
            So its safe to assume all manufacturers nutritional info is based on the milk, full fat cows milk?
            Know of any rule-of-thumb formula for estimating carbs after fermentation?, and presumably the longer its left to ferment, the lower the carbs right?

            1. re: hotoynoodle
              m
              Muchlove RE: hotoynoodle Sep 19, 2011 08:45 AM

              Is this really true? It seems weird that no-one would have the nutritional information for the yoghurt itself.

              1. re: hotoynoodle
                biondanonima RE: hotoynoodle Sep 19, 2011 08:49 AM

                hotoynoodle, are you sure that's true? Fage's labels show 18g of protein and 7g of carbs per 6oz for their 0% yogurt. Skim milk has 6.6g protein and 9.2g carbs per 6oz according to CalorieKing. I don't know about other brands, but clearly Fage is showing the after-fermentation totals.

                1. re: biondanonima
                  hotoynoodle RE: biondanonima Sep 19, 2011 09:08 AM

                  http://www.carbsmart.com/greatyogurt....

                  you can read the rest here, but this is germane:

                  "According to Jack M. Goldberg, Ph.D., and Dr. Karen O'Mara, a cup of yogurt has only 4 grams of carbohydrates. (Dr. Goldberg has actually measured this in his lab.) That is quite a difference from the 14 grams of carbohydrates listed on my yogurt container. The discrepancy can be attributed to the method by which the government requires manufacturers to measure carbohydrates. The "difference" method means manufacturers measure all the different components of a food and anything left is counted as carbohydrates."

                  1. re: hotoynoodle
                    biondanonima RE: hotoynoodle Sep 19, 2011 09:57 AM

                    Hm, very interesting. I wonder if that applies only to strained yogurt, since unstrained yogurt has quite a bit of whey left in it. Good to know, though!

                    1. re: biondanonima
                      hotoynoodle RE: biondanonima Sep 19, 2011 10:25 AM

                      i've been eating low-carb for 2 years and discovering this little nugget a few months ago has allowed me to enjoy yogurt again, a few times per week. finding full-fat versions, though, can be the devil!

            2. re: Kiwi2011
              biondanonima RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 19, 2011 08:44 AM

              I have made it with full fat, 2% and skim milk. All work fine, and I believe the carb count is fairly similar no matter what the fat content.

              1. re: biondanonima
                l
                lilmomma RE: biondanonima Sep 19, 2011 11:25 AM

                Isn;t whey healthy for you?

                1. re: lilmomma
                  m
                  Muchlove RE: lilmomma Sep 19, 2011 11:44 AM

                  Certainly it's something we've never wasted in our house. After making paneer or straining yoghurt (incidentally I don't think this liquid is actually the same as real whey...is it?) we use the liquid in roti dough, add it to dal, etc.

                  1. re: lilmomma
                    biondanonima RE: lilmomma Sep 19, 2011 12:03 PM

                    I wasn't saying that whey is bad for you, it's just not what you want if you're on a low-carb diet. I use the whey from making yogurt in bread, etc.

                    1. re: biondanonima
                      k
                      Kiwi2011 RE: biondanonima Sep 19, 2011 01:39 PM

                      If i leave the mixture longer to ferment will it eat away the carbs

                  2. re: biondanonima
                    k
                    Kiwi2011 RE: biondanonima Sep 20, 2011 01:26 AM

                    With yoghurt, is it a case of the longer you leave it, the thicker it will get and then by definition the lower the number of carbs and Whey to drain of it?

                    1. re: Kiwi2011
                      k
                      Kiwi2011 RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 04:37 AM

                      How much yoghurt do you guys lose in the straining process?

                      1. re: Kiwi2011
                        k
                        Kiwi2011 RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 06:29 AM

                        Any rule of thumb forumla for calculating carbs?

                        1. re: Kiwi2011
                          k
                          Kiwi2011 RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 07:50 AM

                          Will the nutritional data for the new homemade yoghurt be the same as that of the store-bought yoghurt starter?

                          Also, I thought Whey was supposed to be good and FULL of protein.
                          Why is the Whey produced in this process bad?

                          1. re: Kiwi2011
                            m
                            Muchlove RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 09:57 AM

                            I'm going to ask again, is this "whey" strained off yoghurt actually the same as real whey? By real whey I mean the liquid you get when you curdle milk.

                            1. re: Muchlove
                              k
                              Kiwi2011 RE: Muchlove Sep 20, 2011 12:52 PM

                              If I leave the yoghurt for a few days, it becomes even-more solid-like.
                              Is this a good idea to increase the protein content?

                              1. re: Muchlove
                                biondanonima RE: Muchlove Sep 20, 2011 01:50 PM

                                Muchlove, I don't know if it's the same whey as you get when you curdle milk. Wikipedia has a good article that talks about the different types of whey produced from different cheese/dairy making processes.

                                http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whey

                              2. re: Kiwi2011
                                biondanonima RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 01:48 PM

                                The whey is not "bad," it just has carbs in it. If you don't mind a few carbs, use the whey. It does have some protein as well, but it's not pure protein - protein powders are actually made from whey protein isolate, which means they extract the protein from everything else in the whey.

                            2. re: Kiwi2011
                              biondanonima RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 01:45 PM

                              I made yogurt the other day and used 3 quarts of skim milk. When I was done straining, I had one quart of yogurt and two quarts of whey. I like my yogurt quite thick - this batch is a bit thicker than store brands. If I had wanted it to become yogurt cheese, I would have let another pint or so of whey come out.

                            3. re: Kiwi2011
                              biondanonima RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 01:43 PM

                              Your yogurt will thicken a bit the longer you leave it, and become more sour. However, this will result in having MORE whey to strain off of it. As for the carb count, I'm not sure. I don't think you can get it all the way down to zero carbs no matter what you do.

                              1. re: biondanonima
                                k
                                Kiwi2011 RE: biondanonima Sep 22, 2011 04:44 AM

                                What do you think of Paul's kind suggestion below?

                      2. paulj RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 20, 2011 06:27 PM

                        How about adding non-fat dry milk to your milk, and then letting it ferment a generous amount of time. The milk adds both protein and lactose (carbs), the bacteria eats the lactose leaving ??? I assume that if it is quite sour, it has little lactose left. Now if you insist on sweetening the yoghurt with honey, jam or what ever, all bets are off.

                        7 Replies
                        1. re: paulj
                          k
                          Kiwi2011 RE: paulj Sep 22, 2011 04:45 AM

                          Is it always true that more sour = more protein?

                          1. re: Kiwi2011
                            m
                            Muchlove RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 22, 2011 06:57 AM

                            I don't know for sure, and hopefully an expert will weigh in, but I think there are a number of factors that affect the sourness. First, the longer it ferments the sourer it gets which I suppose would make it lower carb as the bacteria feed on more lactose.

                            But I think another important factor is what bacterial strains are in the yoghurt. I say this because on a couple of evenings I've been a bit impatient and added the milk to the yoghurt when it was just a tad too warm. The yoghurt the next day was sourer and since this problem was not rectified when I used a teaspoon of it to make a fresh batch, I decided that maybe I had killed off one type of bacteria by adding the milk at a higher temperature, leaving only a kind of bacteria that made a more sour yoghurt. This is just speculation on my part mind you.

                            1. re: Muchlove
                              k
                              Kiwi2011 RE: Muchlove Sep 22, 2011 08:35 AM

                              Anyone got any tips for making thicker yoghurt?

                              I'll start: Apparently only covering the mixture with a towel and not a plate/lid during fermentation will help.

                              1. re: Kiwi2011
                                m
                                Muchlove RE: Kiwi2011 Sep 22, 2011 09:08 AM

                                I agree it's a good tip. I cover with a mesh lid. If covered with a proper lid you get more liquid on the surface, though the yoghurt itself will still set.

                                Again, I think the bacterial strain makes a huge difference. In the UK my yoghurt was never quite thick enough though it tasted good and was creamy (I was able to get the temperature right so it wasn't that). Here in India it comes out thick everytime with no effort. Doesn't matter if I use full fat buffalo milk, less fatty cows milk, milk that I have skimmed the cream from, etc. I think the yoghurt here must have different strains in it.

                                1. re: Muchlove
                                  k
                                  Kiwi2011 RE: Muchlove Sep 26, 2011 07:34 AM

                                  Another goodie.
                                  Anyone else want to share?

                            2. re: Kiwi2011
                              weezieduzzit RE: Kiwi2011 Aug 23, 2012 03:18 PM

                              "Is it always true that more sour = more protein?"

                              The amount of protein doesn't increase, the amount of carbs decreases. The tartness is because fermentation "eats" the lactose, which is the sweetness.

                              1. re: weezieduzzit
                                e
                                edwardbe RE: weezieduzzit Aug 23, 2012 03:59 PM

                                The tartness is due to lactic acid created by the fermentation of the lactose by the bacteria, so yes, there is less sweetness, but mainly there is more acidity. Removing lactose doesn't by itself make the milk taste sour.

                          2. e
                            edwardbe RE: Kiwi2011 Aug 23, 2012 02:34 PM

                            First of all, stay away from low fat yogurt. Pretty much any commercial product of any type that is labeled low fat has had sugar added to it to make it "taste good" in the absence of the full flavor associated with fat.

                            The real key to low carb diets is fat, not protein. Eating too much protein will cause it to be converted to glucose in a process called gluco-neogenisis, and causes the kind of insulin spike associated with eating carbs.

                            So use full fat milk or better yet use half and half which is much lower in carbs than whole milk.

                            Whey is the protein component of milk, so don't throw it away, in fact, there is no need to separate the yogurt at all, unless you are otherwise eating too much protein. And yes, this is real whey.

                            The bacteria do eat most of the lactose and I have read elsewhere that In Dana Carpenter's cookbook she says that homemade yogurt is 4 grams carbs per 1 cup of yogurt. I would think it is even lower than that if you start with half and half since the half and half only has 10 grams of carbs in the first place.

                            Show Hidden Posts