Eighteen Restaurant, Manhattan
I have been there twice. I liked it both times. The ambiance is really nice for a "grill" type place. Would be perfect. We did a bachelorette dinner there for a friend and it was a big success. They have really good sangria! I got a burger both times and loved it. If you are in the neighborhood you should pop in and see what you think. I would absolutely throw a shower there. Call them and see if they can offer you anything special like mimosas or something shower-y, they would probably do it. They were accommodating of our big group and very nice. We didn't ask for a special menu or anything like that but I felt like they would have worked with us.