Our favorite lobster roll is close to the NF in Hampton Bays @ Canal Cafe, nice big chunks of lobster meat in Ciabatta. Excellent and a nice waterfront setting.
The best on the North Fork is in Greenport @ Chowder Pot Pub. Call ahead since it is on their special menu but usually available. Nice waterfront setting too.
Unfortunately Lobster Roll Northside is below par. Chopped up lobster salad on a hot dog roll does not cut it in my book.
I heard North Fork Table and Inn in Southold was selling lobster rolls from their "food truck" but have not tried it. Call ahead. I drove all the way from Riverhead for lunch and they were closed.
Love Lane Kitchen in Mattituck has a decent lobster roll, also a special, call ahead. The same for Noah's in Greenport which was on the small side.
Chowder Pot Pub
104 3rd St, Greenport, NY 11944
Love Lane Kitchen
240 Love Ln, Mattituck, NY 11952
I've had the one at Love Lane...it was good and I enjoyed it. Haven't tried Lobster Roll Northside as my impression is that it's the 'silver haired set", which isn't what I'm looking for. Also don't want slivers of lobster, but decent' size pieces. Saw someone eat a lobster roll at A Lure this past weekend (will never go back there-rip off royally), and it was a small portion. Ate at the Chowder Pot Pub for the first time about a month ago...enjoyed their food. Will go back and try there.
Any more suggestions? :-)