HOME > Chowhound > Los Angeles Area >

What about Carmine's?

Will Owen Mar 22, 2006 02:44 PM

A friend of my wife's heard someone waxing enthusiastic about this place and asked her about it, and she asked me if there'd been any buzz here. I remember some pro and con remarks a while back, but don't recall any particulars aside from something about flashy-suited wiseguy wannabees hanging out there. Someone care to enlighten us?

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. j
    JBC RE: Will Owen Mar 22, 2006 03:07 PM

    Are you referring to:

    Carmines II
    10463 Santa Monica Blvd.
    Westwood (or WLA)


    4 Replies
    1. re: JBC
      Jill RE: JBC Mar 22, 2006 03:17 PM

      Great old school italian. The meal and service I had there was fantastic.

      1. re: Jill
        Will Owen RE: Jill Mar 22, 2006 03:19 PM

        And which Carmine's was that? Ohhhh, this is SO confusing...

        1. re: Will Owen
          Cecilbee RE: Will Owen Mar 22, 2006 03:39 PM

          The one in So Pas on Fair Oaks. Try the Gumby. Delicious. And the white pizza!

      2. re: JBC
        Will Owen RE: JBC Mar 22, 2006 03:17 PM

        No, Carmine's on Fair Oaks in South Pas. If the earlier thread was about the SM Carmine's, I missed that clue completely.

      3. i
        ipse dixit RE: Will Owen Mar 22, 2006 03:54 PM

        I'd only go to Carmine's for the bar and drinks - fun place to hang out and watch a game or two.

        Food is akin to Olive Garden - not a dining destination by any means.

        1. o
          Oro3030 RE: Will Owen Mar 22, 2006 06:13 PM

          How does it compare (the South Pas one) to my old-school Italian-American standby, Dino's in Pasadena?

          2 Replies
          1. re: Oro3030
            Griller141 RE: Oro3030 Mar 22, 2006 09:45 PM

            Having not been to any of the Carmines, I can say that it (they) are better than Dino's.

            1. re: Griller141
              Oro3030 RE: Griller141 Mar 24, 2006 08:58 PM

              What do you have against Dino's? It is what it is - Italian-American food circa 1955. I think they do a prety good job with those sorts of dishes.

          2. w
            WildSwede RE: Will Owen Mar 22, 2006 07:01 PM

            Hi Will. Okay. Here goes.
            I happen to be a fan of Carmines - both for the happy hour (excellent deals on food) and for dining (although I get delivery from there as well).
            I will get shot for this, but I think their pizza is one of the best I have ever had (better than Casa Bianca, but I have not had the much-fabled sausage/eggplant(?) one from there, but Carmine's pepperoni/mush knocks theirs out of the water) - thin crust, well done. Period. They have a pasta pescatore (you can get it with red, white, pink and some other sauce, I prefer the pink). DELISHUS! They have wonderful soups - both the Minestroni and Lentil. Actually, everything is good. I have not had anything that I have not liked. Took grandma, aunt and cousins who were visiting from Norway here and they could not stop talking about how fresh and wonderful it was. They also offer chicken tenders (not on the menu) - get them with the HOT sauce. I love these. Sometimes I just order these, a side of their mozzarella garlic bread and a side salad and I am a happy girl. Their antipasto salad comes with broccoli florets as well as other veggies. I have always found the service nothing but top notch in the restaurant - however, if you are there for happy hour once you get the waitress place your order - ALL OF IT - since I have found that they tend to disappear as it nears 7 (end of HH). Their bruschetta is fantastic as well. I would definitely give it a try. They have some kind of lemon chicken thing that one of my friends swears by, but I cannot remember any of the details. Their meatballs are her favorite. Calamari is more of a tempura-style coating and is very good.
            They also have a location on Live Oak in Arcadia.
            For the other poster who asked how it compares to Dino's - I just had Dino's for lunch today!! ;-) However, I have never had the spaghetti at Carmine's (my favorite thing at Dino's is the spaghetti with Naploi sauce and I get it every time I go - except for the one time I ordered the pizza, it was okay, but does not come anywhere near Carmine's) so I cannot compare. But I do prefer their house dressing to Carmine's.

            Link: http://www.sangabrielvalleymenus.com/...

            3 Replies
            1. re: WildSwede
              Loke-Go-Eat? RE: WildSwede Mar 22, 2006 08:47 PM

              Next time try the Spaghetti. Top quality pasta that I could enjoy with just some butter. Also, I have been to both the South Pasadena and Arcadia locations and find dem to be da same in food and service. I like da back door takeout in Arcadia because it reminds me of waiting for a pizza one night someplace in Brick City.

              Carmine's (Italian Cheese Steak, Very good pasta in Lasagna, Spaghetti w/ meat sauce -meat balls or sausage, Gumbi,Fettuccini Alfredo, Soups, Pizza, garlic bread, HOWEVER, I say NO to the seafood selections and entrée salads)
              424 Fair Oaks Ave
              South Pasadena, CA 91030
              (626) 799-2266
              (At the 110 – Pasadena Fwy
              Carmine's Same place as above
              311 E Live Oak Ave
              Arcadia, CA 91006
              (626) 445-4726
              East of Santa Anita,

              Link: http://www.sangabrielvalleymenus.com/...

              1. re: WildSwede
                This Guy RE: WildSwede Mar 23, 2006 10:22 PM

                One of the best Pizza's in Town...They are underrated...I might even go as far as better than Casa Bianca's Pizza Pie...and without the 1 1/2 hour wait
                Try the Gumbi...oozing mess of mozzarella cheese and meatballs with al dente rigatoni, mushrooms and meat sauce. YESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!!!

                1. re: WildSwede
                  Oro3030 RE: WildSwede Mar 24, 2006 05:51 PM

                  Thanks for answering my Dino's question. I am a big fan of the chicken parm at Dino's. Tender and not overly-fried.

                2. m
                  mwalton RE: Will Owen Nov 27, 2006 09:10 PM

                  I agree that Carmine's has some of the best pizza. I also love their Tomato and Onion salad. My husband loves their pasta. Big portions at decent prices as well. Karaoke night on Wednesdays are also a blast!

                  Show Hidden Posts