Pizzanista, formerly Toddy G's is making really really great pizza
NY style with some premium ingredients and a premium price tag. Garage pizza and 9th street are good pies but Pizzanista is the best in downtown and is by far my new fav pizza in the city. I was once a slave to the Chicago thin crust style, "Casa Bianca" style pizza but this has officially converted me.
Good to hear they're still churning out good pie even after the brouhaha. If price is a concern, they're still in cahoots with Tony's and doing a slice/beer HH before 7pm, while Tuesdays are $2? slice days. That's almost as cheap as NYC which has its pick of Baker's Bakers pies in every neighborhood.
FWIW, Casa Biana (& Petrillo's) was always just 1 step above Dominoes for me.