HOME > Chowhound > Cookware >


What to Replace AC 3.5 qt Sauce Pan with

Hi everyone,
I have a set of All Clad D5 Cookware that I purchased from Williams Sonoma.
After putting the pieces to the test, I have discovered that I HATE the Sauce Pans.
Currently I have a 3.5 QT., 2 QT and 1.5 QT.

The one I hate to cook with the most is the 3.5 QT is way too heavy to lift with one hand - for example to move contents into a strainer.

I am looking for a replacement that is lighter and easier to handle.

So far I was considering a Chef's Pan/Saucier - Le Creuset seems to have a good one.

I mainly use this type of pot for cooking Frozen Vegetable, Pasta, etc.

Appreciate any help!

  1. Click to Upload a photo (10 MB limit)
  1. I, too, was considering the LC pan. If you get it, let me know how it works.

    You might try the 3.5 qt saucier from American Kitchen. Made in the USA by...Regalware? I think.

    1. Won't LC weigh even more than AC?

      3 Replies
      1. re: Jay F

        Le Creuset's stainless steel line.

        1. re: E_M

          Oh. I thought that had gone away. Is it really lighter than AC stainless?

          Here's the website for American Kitchen: https://www.regalware.com/alt/S/RRETA...

          1. re: Jay F

            Not sure if it is lighter, but it has a helper handle, which makes a world of difference. It also has handy interior capacity markings (as does American Kitchen). I like that.

      2. What about a lighter, more heat-responsive version of that 3.5 qt saucepan with a helper handle? All-Clad's MasterChef2 is two layers of aluminum lined with stainless: http://www.cookwarenmore.com/display....

        1. I have an All Clad original SS 3.5 quart, and an All Clad D5 4 quart with helper handle. The helper handle makes ALL the difference in the world. (I also prefer the pouring lip on the D5).

          Any new AC pieces that I buy will be D5, and I will get it with helper handle if it is available on the size. It is worth the extra money to get the pieces with helper handles.

          4 Replies
          1. re: eliz553

            The D5 3.5 that I have does have a helper handle; however it is way too heavy to hold with one hand and every time I have cooked with it that is what I had to do. Holding the large hand in one hand and the spoon in the other to push the contents into a bowl; way too heavy!

            1. re: raplum

              I looked up the relative weights of the 3-qt. AC, LC, and AK saucepans on amazon. All I could find were the shipping weights. The LC weighs 5 pounds, the other two, 4 pounds.

              1. re: Jay F

                All Clad D5 4-qt. saucepan: 8" diam., 5" high; 4 lb. 14 oz. with lid.

                Le Creuset Stainless Steel 3.5-Quart Chef's Pan with Lid 3.3" H x 9.4" W x 9.4" D 6.7 lbs

                1. re: raplum

                  Hi, raplum:

                  If a 5-lb pan is too heavy, IMO you only have three reasonable choices: (1) a good straight-gauge aluminum pan; (2) the cheapest, thinnest steel or aluminum pan you can find; or (3) a boiling insert to use in a heavier pan.


          2. I would find one with two loop handles instead of one long + one loop handle.

            1 Reply
            1. re: cutipie721

              Agree with cutiepie - what about the All Clad SS soup pot. It's called a soup pot but it's really just a 4 qt sauce pan with two loop handles.

            2. The d5 4 qt soup pot is what I bought instead of the saucepan. It is the same dimensions but has 2 handles. Plus it's on sale right now in the stores for 150 dollars and comes with an all clad ladle.

              I have it and love it.

              3 Replies
              1. re: rasputina

                I have an AC SS 4 qt soup pot - it is actually the first AC piece I purchased - I love it!
                I have also since purchased on sale at WS - the d5 2 qt Saucier/Chef's Pan - love that one too - very easy to maneuver!

                1. re: raplum

                  I have the soup pot also and I HATE it! Ha! I don't like the dimensions--it's too tall for me to easily see into. I have the old SS version.

                  1. re: E_M

                    Mine is the SS version as well but I have no trouble with the dimensions and it's a very versatile pot. I love the double handles.

              2. Take a look at the cuisinart Chefs Classic SS. My brother in law has one of the sets fm Macys and I must say, that the sauce pans are speed demons for heating up. Nice and light too.