Jean-Georges Steakhouse or Prime?
I'm having a 10-person dinner for my bachelor party this fall. I was set for Prime Steakhouse but have also heard great things about the newer JG Steakhouse (whose head chef came from Prime). I've read plenty of reviews comparing each one to other steakhouses, but never to each other. Any suggestions?
Also, what time do people typically go for steak? Would the later seating be more appropriate after a long Saturday?
Having tried nearly all the 'name' steakhouses in town, I can say that JG was the WORST I have been to in years. I felt like I was eating in a nightclub and the steak wasn't cooked correctly and the service was horriffic.
Prime is much better (prices similar), although I do feel they have slipped in the last couple years.
Carnevino is nice, but their service is sloppy and the atmosphere not to my liking. You're practically eating in the Palazzo mall.
Agree with gweilo, if those are your two choices. Ate at JG last week, steaks were bad, apps were bad, and service was the worst we've had in recent memory. It is hard to believe the two places are related. Prime 100%, nicer room as well.
If it is your bachelor party, plan around 830-9. A nice dinner will finish between 11-12 most likely (assuming cocktails, apps, wine, etc.). That's perfect for nightlife whether it be nightclub or that other kind of club. Congrats
I had a great experience at Carnevino and the service was great! The funny thing is that I ate at the bar too and the bartender was awesome. He knew the menu well, offered some recommendations and always stayed on top of my drink needs. The steak I had was cooked perfectly and seasoned well. My only gripe is that I'm a Ribeye kind of guy and they only served a Ribeye for two.
You may want to look into n9ne steakhouse @ the Palms. The night I proposed to my wife, I had dinner reservations there afterwards. The service was excellent and everything we had that night was on point. I was very impressed. They worked with me on getting a dozen roses delivered and rose petals set up on the table. They also comped us this HUGE marble slab of dessert choices ( I think like 5 or 6 different ones and some cookies and stuff too). They were very accomodating. The vibe of the room is very hip, loud, and not stuffy at all. Then it's just a short elevator ride up to the roof to check out Ghostbar or Playboy Club to get the night started. Just a thought...
- The original comment has been removed